"But every historical statement and legitimization itself moves within a certain relation to history"
About this Quote
History is never just a warehouse of facts; it is a field we stand inside, already oriented, already implicated. Heidegger’s line is doing a quiet but ruthless piece of philosophical housekeeping: it denies the fantasy that we can make “historical statements” from nowhere, as if the past were an object on a table and the historian a neutral pair of eyes. Even “legitimization” - the attempt to authorize a narrative, a regime, a tradition, a self-image - doesn’t hover above events. It operates within a “relation to history,” meaning a prior stance about what counts as meaningful, what deserves continuity, what gets dismissed as noise.
The subtext is methodological and political at once. Methodological, because Heidegger is pressing the point that interpretation is not a defect added to history; it is the medium through which history becomes intelligible at all. Political, because legitimization is how institutions launder power into inevitability. If every act of justification is itself historically situated, then appeals to “the lessons of history” are suspect not because they’re false, but because they’re interested. They’re moves in a game whose rules were also inherited.
Context matters: Heidegger is writing in the wake of historicism’s rise, when scholars treated history as the master key to meaning, and also amid Europe’s crisis of tradition and authority. The sentence reads like a warning label. Don’t mistake your story about the past for the past itself. Don’t confuse legitimacy with truth. Your account is part of history’s ongoing struggle over what will be remembered, and on whose terms.
The subtext is methodological and political at once. Methodological, because Heidegger is pressing the point that interpretation is not a defect added to history; it is the medium through which history becomes intelligible at all. Political, because legitimization is how institutions launder power into inevitability. If every act of justification is itself historically situated, then appeals to “the lessons of history” are suspect not because they’re false, but because they’re interested. They’re moves in a game whose rules were also inherited.
Context matters: Heidegger is writing in the wake of historicism’s rise, when scholars treated history as the master key to meaning, and also amid Europe’s crisis of tradition and authority. The sentence reads like a warning label. Don’t mistake your story about the past for the past itself. Don’t confuse legitimacy with truth. Your account is part of history’s ongoing struggle over what will be remembered, and on whose terms.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Martin
Add to List








