"But fantasy kills imagination, pornography is death to art"
About this Quote
Murdoch lands a provocation that sounds backwards on purpose: fantasy, the supposed playground of imagination, is what strangles it. The line works because it treats certain kinds of “freedom” as pre-fabricated. Fantasy here isn’t the expansive, world-making kind; it’s the private daydream that runs on autopilot, feeding you exactly what you already want. It’s imagination with the risk removed, a closed circuit of desire. Murdoch’s target is less genre than habit: the mind rehearsing gratifying scenarios until reality, with its stubborn otherness, starts to feel like an interruption.
The second clause sharpens the blade. “Pornography” functions as the extreme case of fantasy’s moral and aesthetic failure: the reduction of a person to a consumable image, a script with no surprise. Calling it “death to art” isn’t prudishness; it’s an argument about attention. Art, for Murdoch, depends on the discipline of looking outward, of granting complexity to what is not you. Pornography, in her framing, is the opposite discipline: training the eye to flatten, to speed-run to payoff, to treat the world as a vending machine.
Context matters: Murdoch writes out of a mid-century moral philosophy concerned with freedom, ego, and the difficulty of genuine love. The line is a warning about how easily the self colonizes experience. Imagination survives on resistance - on the real pushing back. Fantasy that never loses, never learns, never encounters the unchosen is not a gateway; it’s a cul-de-sac.
The second clause sharpens the blade. “Pornography” functions as the extreme case of fantasy’s moral and aesthetic failure: the reduction of a person to a consumable image, a script with no surprise. Calling it “death to art” isn’t prudishness; it’s an argument about attention. Art, for Murdoch, depends on the discipline of looking outward, of granting complexity to what is not you. Pornography, in her framing, is the opposite discipline: training the eye to flatten, to speed-run to payoff, to treat the world as a vending machine.
Context matters: Murdoch writes out of a mid-century moral philosophy concerned with freedom, ego, and the difficulty of genuine love. The line is a warning about how easily the self colonizes experience. Imagination survives on resistance - on the real pushing back. Fantasy that never loses, never learns, never encounters the unchosen is not a gateway; it’s a cul-de-sac.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Iris
Add to List





