"But human experience is usually paradoxical, that means incongruous with the phrases of current talk or even current philosophy"
About this Quote
Eliot is taking a quiet swing at the era’s most comforting vice: thinking that if you can name a thing neatly, you’ve understood it. “Paradoxical” here isn’t a party trick or a clever contradiction. It’s her diagnosis of lived reality as stubbornly ill-fitting to the ready-made language a culture hands you. The barb lands in “current talk” and “current philosophy” - the phrases that circulate like currency, making people feel up to date while sanding down the jaggedness of actual life.
The intent is both moral and aesthetic. Eliot wrote novels built to prove that motives are mixed, consequences ricochet, and goodness can arrive looking like failure. In mid-Victorian Britain, public “talk” about respectability, gender roles, faith, and progress was thick with slogans. “Current philosophy” nods to the big intellectual systems of her time - utilitarian calculus, doctrinal religion, confident rationalism - frameworks that promise coherence. Eliot’s point is that coherence is often the seduction, not the truth.
Subtext: beware the social pressure to speak in fashionable abstractions. When we adopt a pre-approved vocabulary, we start editing our experience to match it. Eliot’s realism is a resistance movement against that editing. She insists that sympathy begins where a person stops sounding like a type. The line works because it makes “paradox” feel less like an idea and more like a daily inconvenience: life keeps failing to quote our theories back to us.
The intent is both moral and aesthetic. Eliot wrote novels built to prove that motives are mixed, consequences ricochet, and goodness can arrive looking like failure. In mid-Victorian Britain, public “talk” about respectability, gender roles, faith, and progress was thick with slogans. “Current philosophy” nods to the big intellectual systems of her time - utilitarian calculus, doctrinal religion, confident rationalism - frameworks that promise coherence. Eliot’s point is that coherence is often the seduction, not the truth.
Subtext: beware the social pressure to speak in fashionable abstractions. When we adopt a pre-approved vocabulary, we start editing our experience to match it. Eliot’s realism is a resistance movement against that editing. She insists that sympathy begins where a person stops sounding like a type. The line works because it makes “paradox” feel less like an idea and more like a daily inconvenience: life keeps failing to quote our theories back to us.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by George
Add to List
