"But I think doctors have always been either honest or dishonest"
About this Quote
Baskin’s line lands like a shrug that’s also an accusation: the real variable in medicine isn’t technology, fashion, or bedside manner, but character. Coming from an artist who spent a career engraving the human figure with unsparing clarity, it reads less like a sociological claim than a moral incision. He’s not arguing that doctors are good or bad. He’s insisting that the profession’s central drama has always been ethical, not procedural.
The blunt binary - honest or dishonest - is doing strategic work. It refuses the comforting middle categories we use to make institutions feel stable: “well-intentioned,” “overworked,” “part of a broken system.” Baskin’s phrasing implies that medicine, precisely because it trades in vulnerability, offers unusually fertile ground for self-deception and for exploitation. You can hide behind expertise, behind Latin, behind the mystique of the white coat; honesty becomes not a personality trait but a daily choice against the seductions of authority.
Context matters: Baskin came of age in a century when medicine’s prestige soared alongside its capacity for harm - from paternalistic secrecy to eugenics-adjacent thinking, from miracle cures to iatrogenic disasters. His sentence compresses that history into a verdict that’s almost ancient: the tools change, the temptation doesn’t.
There’s also an artist’s impatience here. Baskin distrusts professional narratives that launder responsibility. He pins the viewer - or the patient - to a simple, unnerving question: when you’re powerless on the table, is the person standing over you telling the truth?
The blunt binary - honest or dishonest - is doing strategic work. It refuses the comforting middle categories we use to make institutions feel stable: “well-intentioned,” “overworked,” “part of a broken system.” Baskin’s phrasing implies that medicine, precisely because it trades in vulnerability, offers unusually fertile ground for self-deception and for exploitation. You can hide behind expertise, behind Latin, behind the mystique of the white coat; honesty becomes not a personality trait but a daily choice against the seductions of authority.
Context matters: Baskin came of age in a century when medicine’s prestige soared alongside its capacity for harm - from paternalistic secrecy to eugenics-adjacent thinking, from miracle cures to iatrogenic disasters. His sentence compresses that history into a verdict that’s almost ancient: the tools change, the temptation doesn’t.
There’s also an artist’s impatience here. Baskin distrusts professional narratives that launder responsibility. He pins the viewer - or the patient - to a simple, unnerving question: when you’re powerless on the table, is the person standing over you telling the truth?
Quote Details
| Topic | Doctor |
|---|
More Quotes by Leonard
Add to List







