"But, if you observe children learning in their first few years of life, you can see that they can and do learn on their own - we leave them alone to crawl, walk, talk, and gain control over their bodies. It happens without much help from parents"
About this Quote
Greenberg’s argument lands by pointing to the one classroom nobody disputes: early childhood. Crawl-to-walk, babble-to-speech, clumsy hands to coordinated bodies: these are not “taught” in the lesson-plan sense, yet they happen with relentless momentum. The intent is clear: if humans can master the most complex skill set imaginable (language, motor control, social cues) with minimal direct instruction, the default assumption that schooling requires constant adult management starts to look less like common sense and more like cultural habit.
The subtext is a critique of institutionalized insecurity. Modern education often treats children as projects that must be engineered, measured, and corrected, as if learning were an industrial process with quality control. Greenberg flips that: adults are less the engines of learning than the custodians of conditions. “It happens without much help” doesn’t romanticize neglect; it reframes help as space, safety, and time rather than explanation and coercion. The provocation is aimed at overparenting and over-schooling alike: when we hover, we can end up substituting compliance for competence.
Context matters because Greenberg is associated with the Sudbury school model, which treats self-directed learning as the baseline and adult authority as deliberately limited. Read that way, the quote isn’t just developmental psychology; it’s political theory in miniature. It implies that autonomy is not a reward for finishing education but the precondition that makes real education possible.
The subtext is a critique of institutionalized insecurity. Modern education often treats children as projects that must be engineered, measured, and corrected, as if learning were an industrial process with quality control. Greenberg flips that: adults are less the engines of learning than the custodians of conditions. “It happens without much help” doesn’t romanticize neglect; it reframes help as space, safety, and time rather than explanation and coercion. The provocation is aimed at overparenting and over-schooling alike: when we hover, we can end up substituting compliance for competence.
Context matters because Greenberg is associated with the Sudbury school model, which treats self-directed learning as the baseline and adult authority as deliberately limited. Read that way, the quote isn’t just developmental psychology; it’s political theory in miniature. It implies that autonomy is not a reward for finishing education but the precondition that makes real education possible.
Quote Details
| Topic | Parenting |
|---|
More Quotes by Daniel
Add to List
