"But it so happens, and it will ever happen so, that they who have lived to serve their country - no matter how weak their efforts may have been - are sure to receive the thanks and blessings of its people"
About this Quote
The subtext, though, is more complicated. "Are sure to receive" and "will ever happen so" have the ring of a promise that needs to be repeated because reality keeps contradicting it. In Meagher's 19th-century world, veterans regularly returned to political indifference, material hardship, and public amnesia. The insistence on inevitability reads like a kind of rhetorical armor: if society fails to honor you now, it is society that is breaking the natural order.
Context sharpens the purpose. Meagher, an Irish nationalist turned Union general and later a political figure in the American West, lived inside a transatlantic culture where martial service was a pathway to legitimacy for outsiders. For an immigrant community often treated as suspect, the idea that service converts weakness into blessing is not just flattery; it's strategy. He is recruiting loyalty while also demanding recognition: if the country wants defenders, it must become the kind of country that remembers them.
Quote Details
| Topic | Military & Soldier |
|---|---|
| Source | Verified source: Speech From the Dock (Thomas F. Meagher, 1848)
Evidence: But it so happens, and it will ever happen so, that they who have lived to serve their country, no matter how weak their efforts may have been, are sure to receive the thanks and blessings of its people. (Primary text located in Project Gutenberg transcription, lines 947-949; exact original pamphlet/page not confirmed). This wording appears in Thomas Francis Meagher's speech delivered from the dock at Clonmel after his conviction for treason in October 1848. The commonly circulated variant 'they who have tried to serve their country' is not the primary wording in the text I verified; the verified text reads 'lived to serve their country.' The speech is widely known as Meagher's 'Speech From the Dock.' I verified the passage in a primary-text transcription hosted by Project Gutenberg, where the relevant lines are 947-949. Search evidence also ties the occasion to sentencing at Clonmel on October 22, 1848, though the exact first print appearance and original page number in an 1848 pamphlet/newspaper could not be conclusively established from the sources I could access. Other candidates (1) "Guilty Or Not Guilty?" (Timothy Daniel Sullivan, 1867) compilation99.4% ... But it so happens , and it will ever happen so , that they who have lived to serve their country - no matter how ... |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Meagher, Thomas F. (2026, March 8). But it so happens, and it will ever happen so, that they who have lived to serve their country - no matter how weak their efforts may have been - are sure to receive the thanks and blessings of its people. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/but-it-so-happens-and-it-will-ever-happen-so-that-156095/
Chicago Style
Meagher, Thomas F. "But it so happens, and it will ever happen so, that they who have lived to serve their country - no matter how weak their efforts may have been - are sure to receive the thanks and blessings of its people." FixQuotes. March 8, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/but-it-so-happens-and-it-will-ever-happen-so-that-156095/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"But it so happens, and it will ever happen so, that they who have lived to serve their country - no matter how weak their efforts may have been - are sure to receive the thanks and blessings of its people." FixQuotes, 8 Mar. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/but-it-so-happens-and-it-will-ever-happen-so-that-156095/. Accessed 26 Mar. 2026.




