"But men are men; the best sometimes forget"
About this Quote
Shakespeare’s line lands like a shrug with a dagger inside it: a pocket-sized excuse for betrayal that sounds humane right up until you hear how much damage it can authorize. “But men are men” is the old-world equivalent of a moral waiver form. It doesn’t argue; it normalizes. The semicolon is doing heavy lifting, pivoting from sweeping generalization to the quieter, more insidious claim: even “the best” lapse. Once virtue is framed as something that merely “sometimes forget[s],” wrongdoing becomes a momentary mental slip rather than a choice with consequences.
The intent is less to absolve than to manage expectations. In Shakespeare’s dramatic universe, people aren’t divided into saints and villains; they’re divided into those who can narrate their impulses convincingly and those who can’t. This line belongs to the former camp. It’s rhetoric designed to soften judgment, to pre-empt outrage, to coach an audience (or another character) into accepting disappointment as mature realism. Cynicism masquerades as wisdom.
The subtext is also gendered in a way that feels eerily current. “Men are men” treats male fallibility as a law of nature, not a social arrangement. It’s the seed of every later defense that turns harm into inevitability: boys will be boys, powerful men will stray, desire will overrule duty. Shakespeare isn’t endorsing it so much as dramatizing how easily language can launder guilt. The line’s brilliance is its plausibility; it sounds like compassion, and that’s why it’s dangerous.
The intent is less to absolve than to manage expectations. In Shakespeare’s dramatic universe, people aren’t divided into saints and villains; they’re divided into those who can narrate their impulses convincingly and those who can’t. This line belongs to the former camp. It’s rhetoric designed to soften judgment, to pre-empt outrage, to coach an audience (or another character) into accepting disappointment as mature realism. Cynicism masquerades as wisdom.
The subtext is also gendered in a way that feels eerily current. “Men are men” treats male fallibility as a law of nature, not a social arrangement. It’s the seed of every later defense that turns harm into inevitability: boys will be boys, powerful men will stray, desire will overrule duty. Shakespeare isn’t endorsing it so much as dramatizing how easily language can launder guilt. The line’s brilliance is its plausibility; it sounds like compassion, and that’s why it’s dangerous.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by William
Add to List






