"But no work from a first rate mind is ever really second rate"
About this Quote
Finzi’s line is a quiet rebuke to the ranking impulse that hovers over classical music: the idea that even great composers have “minor” works you can politely skip. Coming from a composer who lived in the long shadow of canonical giants and died before his reputation fully settled, it reads less like a slogan than a survival ethic. He’s defending the integrity of serious craft against the lazy shorthand of prestige.
The key move is the phrasing “ever really.” Finzi concedes the surface reality of hierarchy - yes, audiences and critics label pieces as second-tier - then undercuts it with a deeper claim about what a “first rate mind” deposits in everything it touches. Even when the material is modest, the thinking isn’t. In music, that can mean harmonic decisions that feel inevitable, a melodic line that knows exactly where it’s going, or an emotional truth that doesn’t depend on scale or spectacle. A small song can carry the same intelligence as a symphony; the medium isn’t the measure.
There’s also a pointed subtext about time. “Second rate” is often just a placeholder for “not yet understood,” “out of fashion,” or “doesn’t fit the narrative we’ve built around genius.” Finzi is pushing back against the museum model of culture, where reputations harden and listening becomes a checklist. It’s an invitation to hear works as evidence of a mind at work, not as entries in a league table.
The key move is the phrasing “ever really.” Finzi concedes the surface reality of hierarchy - yes, audiences and critics label pieces as second-tier - then undercuts it with a deeper claim about what a “first rate mind” deposits in everything it touches. Even when the material is modest, the thinking isn’t. In music, that can mean harmonic decisions that feel inevitable, a melodic line that knows exactly where it’s going, or an emotional truth that doesn’t depend on scale or spectacle. A small song can carry the same intelligence as a symphony; the medium isn’t the measure.
There’s also a pointed subtext about time. “Second rate” is often just a placeholder for “not yet understood,” “out of fashion,” or “doesn’t fit the narrative we’ve built around genius.” Finzi is pushing back against the museum model of culture, where reputations harden and listening becomes a checklist. It’s an invitation to hear works as evidence of a mind at work, not as entries in a league table.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Gerald
Add to List






