Politics & Power Quote by Terry Savage

"But only 'rich' people by definition have the 'extra' money to buy things and invest to create economic growth. Do we really want to tax that 'extra' money away - and give it to the government to spend? Does that make any economic sense outside of politics and our emotional desire to make everyone suffer equally through these tough times?"

Terry Savage, Writer

About this Quote

Savage’s line of attack is to smuggle a moral argument into an economic one, then dare you to disagree without sounding petty. The scare quotes around "rich" and "extra" do a lot of work: they hint that the category is slippery, maybe even unfairly demonized, while also insisting that surplus cash is not indulgence but fuel. In her framing, money sitting with the wealthy isn’t stagnant; it’s potential investment, jobs, growth. Tax it and you’re not redistributing comfort, you’re draining the engine.

The rhetorical questions are calibrated to close the argument rather than open it. "Do we really want..". presumes a shared, sensible "we" that already knows the answer. Government is cast as a spendthrift middleman, not a buyer of public goods, and that omission is the point: if you never mention infrastructure, research, health, education, or demand-stabilizing programs, "give it to the government to spend" sounds like pure waste.

Then comes the emotional trap: opposition is reduced to "politics" and a mean-spirited urge to "make everyone suffer equally". That’s not just a critique of redistribution; it’s a preemptive character judgment. The subtext is a recession-era anxiety (or any "tough times") where calls to "share the burden" can feel like punishment. Savage’s intent is to reframe tax policy as envy dressed up as compassion, and to make defending wealth retention sound like defending recovery itself.

Quote Details

Topic	Wealth
Source	Help us find the source
Cite

More Quotes by Terry Add to List

About the Author

Terry Savage is a Writer from USA.

3 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

"Government spending is taxation. When you look at this, I've never heard of a poor person spending himself into prosperity; let alone, I've never heard of a poor person taxing himself into prosperity"

Arthur Laffer, Economist

Arthur Laffer

"So if we are really concerned about generating more taxes, we ought to be investing in our people, not taking away the kinds of resources that contribute to their ability to become greater taxpayers in this country"

Patrick J. Kennedy, Politician

"People really have to believe in their tax system. They have to believe that there is an equitable distribution of the burden, but there is also an important investment based upon the potential achievements that come from us paying our taxes!"

Richard Neal, Politician

"And I just think that we're at a point in our economic life here in our state - and - and, candidly, across the country, where increased taxes is just the wrong way to go. The people of our state are not convinced that state government, county government, local government has done all they can with the money we already give them, rather than the money that we have before"

Chris Christie, Politician

"When we leave money in the hands of taxpayers, they buy things, they pay taxes, they grow government"

Ken Buck, Politician

"People try to live within their income so they can afford to pay taxes to a government that can't live within its income"

Robert Half, Businessman

"Tax bills create wealth. They help people live better"

Nancy Johnson, Politician

"In these times of the 'Great Recession', we shouldn't be trying to shift the benefits of wealth behind some curtain. We should be celebrating and encouraging people to make as much money as they can. Profits equal tax money. While some people might find it distasteful to pay taxes, I don't. I find it patriotic"

Mark Cuban, Businessman

"I am neither a free-trade man, willing to collect all the money we have to raise by direct tax upon the people, nor am I willing to lay a tax simply for protection when the Government does not need the money"

Joseph E. Brown, Politician

"If anything, taxes for the lower and middle class and maybe even the upper middle class should even probably be cut further. But I think that people at the high end - people like myself - should be paying a lot more in taxes. We have it better than we've ever had it"

Warren Buffett, Businessman

Warren Buffett

"I believe that all the measures of the Government are directed to the purpose of making the rich richer and the poor poorer"

William Henry Harrison, President

William Henry Harrison

"The tax code is not the only area where the administration is helping the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. It has spent $155 billion for an unnecessary war driven by fear"

Dennis Kucinich, Politician

"If we increase spending, we have got to raise taxes or any combination"

Bobby Scott, Politician

"You have to take away some of tax breaks for the wealthy, and you have to cut back on some entitlements. Because, unless we do all of these things, it just doesn't work. And what's good theater and what's good politics isn't necessarily good economic policy"

Michael Bloomberg, Politician

"Instead of raising taxes as some would insist, we need to reduce waste and inefficiency in government"

Tim Murphy, Politician

"No, I'm not rich. I had a tax problem in this country, curiously enough, and my accountant said the British government was patently wrong in taxing me, and they were, but we couldn't persuade them and it cost me everything I had"

Donald Sutherland, Actor

"The death tax punishes the American dream - making it virtually impossible for the average American family to build wealth across generations"

Kit Bond, Politician

"Well, the taxes that everyone else is paying are supporting lots of programs that were in place prior to Obama's new spending. So new spending has too be paid for by new taxes, or by eliminating existing tax breaks. And Obama wants that burden to be borne exclusively by the rich"

Dinesh D'Souza, Author

"Taxation is just a sophisticated way of demanding money with menaces"

Terry Pratchett, Author

Terry Pratchett

"The rich pay more in total taxes now than ever before - ever. It's true. Just like it's true that when the rich are convinced they're going to be taxed more, they spend less. And when the top few percenters don't spend, there goes all your spending, because they account for half of all retail spending"

Neil Cavuto, Journalist