"But someone like Claude Chabrol tries to make a connection between the society in which we live and the social reasons which make monsters out of some people"
About this Quote
Huppert isn’t praising Chabrol for “social commentary” in the tasteful, awards-season sense. She’s pointing to his specific talent for making evil feel uncomfortably local: not a supernatural glitch, not a lone psychopath dropped from the sky, but a human product with a return address. The key phrase is “tries to make a connection” - it admits the work is risky, maybe even doomed to fail cleanly. Chabrol’s cinema doesn’t offer a neat causal chain where poverty or bad parenting explains everything. It shows how a polished society manufactures its own aberrations, then pretends to be shocked when they appear.
The subtext is a quiet rebuke to the way audiences like their monsters quarantined. Calling someone a monster is emotionally efficient; it protects the rest of us from recognition. Huppert’s framing tugs that protection away. “The society in which we live” implicates viewers, critics, and bourgeois comfort - the very milieu Chabrol loved to dissect. “Social reasons” suggests mechanisms rather than morals: class pressure, hypocrisy, misogyny, family performance, reputational economies. You don’t have to endorse the violence to see the scaffolding that holds it up.
Context matters because Huppert is also describing her own screen persona, sharpened in Chabrol collaborations: characters who aren’t case studies but pressure points. The intent isn’t absolution; it’s diagnosis. The discomfort is the point. When art connects the monster to the living room, it stops being entertainment and becomes an accusation.
The subtext is a quiet rebuke to the way audiences like their monsters quarantined. Calling someone a monster is emotionally efficient; it protects the rest of us from recognition. Huppert’s framing tugs that protection away. “The society in which we live” implicates viewers, critics, and bourgeois comfort - the very milieu Chabrol loved to dissect. “Social reasons” suggests mechanisms rather than morals: class pressure, hypocrisy, misogyny, family performance, reputational economies. You don’t have to endorse the violence to see the scaffolding that holds it up.
Context matters because Huppert is also describing her own screen persona, sharpened in Chabrol collaborations: characters who aren’t case studies but pressure points. The intent isn’t absolution; it’s diagnosis. The discomfort is the point. When art connects the monster to the living room, it stops being entertainment and becomes an accusation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Isabelle
Add to List





