"But the greatest thing about music is putting it out there for people to figure out. You want the listener to find the song on their own. If you give too much away, it takes away from the imagination"
About this Quote
Krall is defending the art of leaving the door open. In an era where musicians are expected to narrate every lyric on social media, annotate their own metaphors, and package albums with ready-made “meaning,” she argues for the opposite: trust the listener’s private intelligence. The line “putting it out there for people to figure out” frames music less as a message delivered and more as an invitation issued. It’s a creative ethic that quietly resists the content-economy demand for instant clarity.
The subtext is about control. Artists can hoard interpretation the way brands hoard messaging, but Krall suggests that over-explaining is a kind of artistic micromanagement. “If you give too much away” isn’t just about spoilers; it’s about closing the imaginative loop before it has a chance to form. A song becomes smaller when it’s pinned down to a single anecdote or authorized reading. Her phrasing puts the burden - and the power - on the audience: the listener doesn’t receive meaning, they discover it.
Coming from a jazz musician known for restraint, space, and phrasing that implies more than it states, the idea fits the form. Jazz has always been about what’s suggested: the pause, the unresolved chord, the emotional information carried by tone rather than exposition. Krall’s intent is almost pedagogical: she’s training us to listen actively, to meet the music halfway. In that exchange, imagination isn’t a bonus feature; it’s the instrument that completes the song.
The subtext is about control. Artists can hoard interpretation the way brands hoard messaging, but Krall suggests that over-explaining is a kind of artistic micromanagement. “If you give too much away” isn’t just about spoilers; it’s about closing the imaginative loop before it has a chance to form. A song becomes smaller when it’s pinned down to a single anecdote or authorized reading. Her phrasing puts the burden - and the power - on the audience: the listener doesn’t receive meaning, they discover it.
Coming from a jazz musician known for restraint, space, and phrasing that implies more than it states, the idea fits the form. Jazz has always been about what’s suggested: the pause, the unresolved chord, the emotional information carried by tone rather than exposition. Krall’s intent is almost pedagogical: she’s training us to listen actively, to meet the music halfway. In that exchange, imagination isn’t a bonus feature; it’s the instrument that completes the song.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Diana
Add to List




