"Can someone within that society walk into the town square and say what they want without fear of being punished for his or her views? If so, then that society is a free society. If not, it is a fear society"
About this Quote
Freedom, for Sharansky, isn’t a vibe or a flag-waving abstraction; it’s a stress test. The “town square” is a deliberately ordinary stage, not a courtroom or a parliament. He’s asking whether dissent survives daylight in the most public, socially policed space a community has. The brilliance is the simplicity: if a society is truly free, it can tolerate the messy, unpopular, even offensive thing said out loud, by a person without connections, without protection. The metric isn’t the constitution on paper. It’s the stomach for embarrassment and conflict.
The phrasing carries the residue of Sharansky’s biography: a Soviet Jewish dissident turned prisoner, later an Israeli politician, whose life taught him that censorship rarely announces itself as tyranny. It arrives as consequences: losing a job, being surveilled, getting hauled in “for questioning.” So “punished” does quiet work here. It’s not just prison; it’s the ecosystem of retaliation that makes citizens self-censor, which is often more efficient than any secret police.
His binary - free society versus “fear society” - is intentionally blunt, almost prosecutorial. It leaves little room for the comforting gray zones that let regimes, institutions, even democracies dodge accountability: “We have free speech, just don’t say that.” The subtext is a warning to the West as much as a critique of dictatorships: the moment public opinion, employers, or the state can credibly threaten you for your views, fear becomes a governing technology. Freedom isn’t measured by what leaders permit; it’s measured by what ordinary people dare.
The phrasing carries the residue of Sharansky’s biography: a Soviet Jewish dissident turned prisoner, later an Israeli politician, whose life taught him that censorship rarely announces itself as tyranny. It arrives as consequences: losing a job, being surveilled, getting hauled in “for questioning.” So “punished” does quiet work here. It’s not just prison; it’s the ecosystem of retaliation that makes citizens self-censor, which is often more efficient than any secret police.
His binary - free society versus “fear society” - is intentionally blunt, almost prosecutorial. It leaves little room for the comforting gray zones that let regimes, institutions, even democracies dodge accountability: “We have free speech, just don’t say that.” The subtext is a warning to the West as much as a critique of dictatorships: the moment public opinion, employers, or the state can credibly threaten you for your views, fear becomes a governing technology. Freedom isn’t measured by what leaders permit; it’s measured by what ordinary people dare.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Natan
Add to List
