"Canada is in budgetary deficit now only because of the recession, only because of stimulus measures, and we will come out of it. We will go back into surplus position when the economy recovers. So there is no need in Canada to raise taxes"
About this Quote
Harper’s line is austerity dressed up as reassurance: the deficit is framed as a temporary weather system, not a structural feature of the house. By pinning red ink “only” on the recession and “only” on stimulus, he compresses a complicated fiscal story into a clean, morally legible narrative: good managers ran a sound ship, an external storm hit, emergency spending happened, and normal order will resume. The repetition of “only” isn’t just emphasis; it’s a preemptive strike against critics who might argue the deficit reflects policy choices, not fate.
The political intent is equally tidy. “We will go back into surplus” offers certainty without dates, a promise that can’t easily be falsified in the short term. It’s an act of narrative control: make the recovery do the heavy lifting, and the government gets credit for patience rather than pain. Then comes the real payload: “no need...to raise taxes.” That’s not a fiscal conclusion so much as a boundary-setting move in an ideological fight. If the deficit is temporary and self-correcting, taxes become not a tool but a betrayal.
Context matters: post-2008, conservatives across the West were trying to justify stimulus as an exceptional, time-limited detour while keeping the long-term brand intact. Harper’s phrasing signals to two audiences at once: centrists get calm competence, the base gets tax-hike inoculation. The subtext is that government should wait, not redesign; that revenue isn’t the problem, discipline is.
The political intent is equally tidy. “We will go back into surplus” offers certainty without dates, a promise that can’t easily be falsified in the short term. It’s an act of narrative control: make the recovery do the heavy lifting, and the government gets credit for patience rather than pain. Then comes the real payload: “no need...to raise taxes.” That’s not a fiscal conclusion so much as a boundary-setting move in an ideological fight. If the deficit is temporary and self-correcting, taxes become not a tool but a betrayal.
Context matters: post-2008, conservatives across the West were trying to justify stimulus as an exceptional, time-limited detour while keeping the long-term brand intact. Harper’s phrasing signals to two audiences at once: centrists get calm competence, the base gets tax-hike inoculation. The subtext is that government should wait, not redesign; that revenue isn’t the problem, discipline is.
Quote Details
| Topic | Money |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Stephen
Add to List




