"Certain elements may try to stretch this beyond what it is"
About this Quote
Certain elements may try to stretch this beyond what it is: a sentence engineered to sound reasonable while refusing to concede anything. Ziegler, as Nixon's press secretary, lived in the seam between event and narrative, and this line is pure seamwork. "Certain elements" is the first sleight of hand. It gestures at enemies without naming them, turning journalists, critics, prosecutors, even internal dissenters into a vague, slightly sinister blur. The phrase implies coordination and bad faith; it invites the public to suspect manipulation rather than investigate facts.
"Try to stretch" is the second move. It frames scrutiny as distortion. Instead of acknowledging that new information might legitimately expand the story, Ziegler preemptively casts expansion as exaggeration. The verb smuggles in an assumption: the underlying matter is inherently small and stable, and anyone describing it as larger is actively warping it.
Then comes the clincher: "beyond what it is". That's an assertion of epistemic authority without evidence. It positions the speaker as the custodian of the real, the adult in the room, even as it withholds specifics. In the Nixon-era media environment, where televised briefings turned politics into a daily performance, that posture mattered. It's not meant to persuade skeptics; it's meant to give allies a script and fence-sitters an easy off-ramp: don't overthink it, don't feed the frenzy.
The subtext is defensive discipline: keep the story narrow, keep responsibility diffuse, and treat curiosity as opportunism. It's crisis communication as moral insinuation.
"Try to stretch" is the second move. It frames scrutiny as distortion. Instead of acknowledging that new information might legitimately expand the story, Ziegler preemptively casts expansion as exaggeration. The verb smuggles in an assumption: the underlying matter is inherently small and stable, and anyone describing it as larger is actively warping it.
Then comes the clincher: "beyond what it is". That's an assertion of epistemic authority without evidence. It positions the speaker as the custodian of the real, the adult in the room, even as it withholds specifics. In the Nixon-era media environment, where televised briefings turned politics into a daily performance, that posture mattered. It's not meant to persuade skeptics; it's meant to give allies a script and fence-sitters an easy off-ramp: don't overthink it, don't feed the frenzy.
The subtext is defensive discipline: keep the story narrow, keep responsibility diffuse, and treat curiosity as opportunism. It's crisis communication as moral insinuation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Ron
Add to List





