"Civilization is a progress from an indefinite, incoherent homogeneity toward a definite, coherent heterogeneity"
About this Quote
Spencer’s sentence is the kind of Victorian confidence trick that masquerades as neutral description. It pretends to be pure observation - almost like physics - while smuggling in a whole moral and political worldview. “Progress” is the loaded word: civilization isn’t merely changing, it’s improving, and it’s improving in one direction. The line’s authority comes from its machine-like rhythm: indefinite to definite, incoherent to coherent, homogeneity to heterogeneity. Each pair clicks into place like gears, implying that history has a built-in logic and that Spencer is simply reading its dials.
The subtext is a defense of complexity as destiny. As societies industrialize, specialize, and stratify, Spencer frames the messiness not as exploitation or fracture but as maturation: difference becomes “heterogeneity,” a tidy, almost hygienic term for inequality, hierarchy, and division of labor. By making the end-state “coherent,” he suggests that the social order can be both more unequal and more stable - a useful idea in an era rattled by urban poverty, labor unrest, and the expanding demands of democratic politics.
Context matters: Spencer is writing in the long shadow of Darwin, and he wants an evolutionary story broad enough to cover biology, culture, and economics. That’s why the quote reads like a universal law. It also hints at the dangerous flexibility of “progress” talk in the 19th century: it can diagnose the modern world, justify it, and conveniently rank other societies as “indefinite” or “incoherent” when empire needs a rationale.
The subtext is a defense of complexity as destiny. As societies industrialize, specialize, and stratify, Spencer frames the messiness not as exploitation or fracture but as maturation: difference becomes “heterogeneity,” a tidy, almost hygienic term for inequality, hierarchy, and division of labor. By making the end-state “coherent,” he suggests that the social order can be both more unequal and more stable - a useful idea in an era rattled by urban poverty, labor unrest, and the expanding demands of democratic politics.
Context matters: Spencer is writing in the long shadow of Darwin, and he wants an evolutionary story broad enough to cover biology, culture, and economics. That’s why the quote reads like a universal law. It also hints at the dangerous flexibility of “progress” talk in the 19th century: it can diagnose the modern world, justify it, and conveniently rank other societies as “indefinite” or “incoherent” when empire needs a rationale.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Herbert Spencer , quote listed on Wikiquote (Herbert Spencer page): "Civilization is a progress from an indefinite, incoherent homogeneity toward a definite, coherent heterogeneity". |
More Quotes by Herbert
Add to List







