"Clever people will recognize and tolerate nothing but cleverness"
About this Quote
Aphorisms like this one are seductive because they flatter the reader while quietly indicting them. Amiel’s line sounds like a celebration of intellect, but it’s really an autopsy of a certain intellectual temperament: the clever mind, trained to spot patterns and inconsistencies, can become allergic to anything that doesn’t immediately sparkle. The verb choice matters. “Recognize” implies more than noticing; it’s a stamp of legitimacy. If something isn’t coded as clever, it doesn’t fully register as real or worthy. “Tolerate” is colder still, suggesting that the un-clever isn’t merely boring but almost morally irritating.
The subtext is a warning about cleverness as a value system. Once cleverness becomes the highest coin, everything else gets devalued: sincerity reads as naivete, faith as superstition, steadiness as dullness, moral clarity as simplistic. It’s not hard to hear in this the 19th-century European anxiety about the rise of critique and skepticism, the salon culture that rewarded wit, and the philosophical habit of privileging mind over life. Amiel, a Swiss moralist with a diarist’s sensitivity to self-deception, often wrote from the bruised edge of introspection; he knew how quickly intelligence turns into a defense mechanism.
What makes the line work is its claustrophobic absolutism: “nothing but cleverness.” It’s intentionally extreme, forcing you to feel the impoverishment of a world where only the sharp remark counts. The sting is that the target isn’t fools; it’s the clever who mistake their refinement for superiority, then wonder why nothing moves them anymore.
The subtext is a warning about cleverness as a value system. Once cleverness becomes the highest coin, everything else gets devalued: sincerity reads as naivete, faith as superstition, steadiness as dullness, moral clarity as simplistic. It’s not hard to hear in this the 19th-century European anxiety about the rise of critique and skepticism, the salon culture that rewarded wit, and the philosophical habit of privileging mind over life. Amiel, a Swiss moralist with a diarist’s sensitivity to self-deception, often wrote from the bruised edge of introspection; he knew how quickly intelligence turns into a defense mechanism.
What makes the line work is its claustrophobic absolutism: “nothing but cleverness.” It’s intentionally extreme, forcing you to feel the impoverishment of a world where only the sharp remark counts. The sting is that the target isn’t fools; it’s the clever who mistake their refinement for superiority, then wonder why nothing moves them anymore.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Henri
Add to List
