"Communism destroys democracy. Democracy can also destroy Communism"
About this Quote
Malraux’s line is engineered to sting because it refuses the comforting symmetry of Cold War slogans. “Communism destroys democracy” is the expected diagnosis: a system that claims to speak for “the people” but concentrates power until elections become theater. The twist is the second sentence, where Malraux turns democracy into an active agent, not a fragile victim. “Democracy can also destroy Communism” isn’t a celebration of propaganda or coups; it’s a wager on exposure. Let people vote, argue, publish, unionize, and change governments without bloodshed, and the revolutionary romance starts to look like a bureaucratic grind.
The intent is double-edged: a warning to democrats not to underestimate totalizing ideologies, and a warning to anti-communists not to abandon democratic methods in the name of survival. Malraux had earned the right to be unsentimental. He fought in the Spanish Civil War, moved through the moral wreckage of fascism and Stalinism, and later served in de Gaulle’s France. He’d seen how political absolutes recruit on emotion and then govern through discipline.
The subtext is less about policy than tempo. Communism “destroys” quickly: seize institutions, purge opponents, rewrite the rules. Democracy “destroys” slowly: by making dissent legal, by allowing failure to be visible, by letting citizens compare promises to lived reality. The line flatters neither side. It suggests that democracy’s most potent weapon is its tolerance for contradiction, and that its greatest vulnerability is the temptation to stop tolerating when fear spikes.
The intent is double-edged: a warning to democrats not to underestimate totalizing ideologies, and a warning to anti-communists not to abandon democratic methods in the name of survival. Malraux had earned the right to be unsentimental. He fought in the Spanish Civil War, moved through the moral wreckage of fascism and Stalinism, and later served in de Gaulle’s France. He’d seen how political absolutes recruit on emotion and then govern through discipline.
The subtext is less about policy than tempo. Communism “destroys” quickly: seize institutions, purge opponents, rewrite the rules. Democracy “destroys” slowly: by making dissent legal, by allowing failure to be visible, by letting citizens compare promises to lived reality. The line flatters neither side. It suggests that democracy’s most potent weapon is its tolerance for contradiction, and that its greatest vulnerability is the temptation to stop tolerating when fear spikes.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Andre
Add to List






