"Complete abstinence is easier than perfect moderation"
About this Quote
Augustine distills a paradox of self-mastery: refusing a tempting good entirely can be simpler than calibrating desire precisely. Perfect moderation asks for unwavering discernment in every moment, a fine-grained, continuous act of judgment. Abstinence sets a bright line. It removes the need for constant negotiation with oneself and curbs the inner lawyer that pleads for exceptions.
The insight grows out of Augustine’s own struggles. In the Confessions he prays, "Grant me chastity and continence, but not yet", revealing how desire bends the will even when reason knows the good. He diagnosed the human condition as marked by disordered loves and a divided will. In such a state, moderation is fragile because it relies on steady attention, stable desire, and consistent self-knowledge. Any lapse in clarity can tip moderation into excess. Abstinence, by contrast, simplifies the battlefield: the decision is made once, and the occasions of temptation are reduced.
This logic underlies ascetic practices in Christian tradition and finds echoes in modern psychology. Precommitment, bright-line rules, and minimization of decision fatigue are contemporary ways of saying that clear boundaries conserve moral energy. People who cannot drink just one drink often find sobriety more livable than perpetual micro-calibration. The same dynamic appears with gambling, pornography, or compulsive scrolling.
Yet Augustine is not exalting deprivation for its own sake. He affirms the goodness of creation and the virtue of temperance. The point is prudential: for fallen creatures, perfect moderation is the harder art, and failure can be ruinous. Abstinence becomes a strategy for reordering love and regaining freedom. There is also a warning here. What looks like sheer willpower depends, in Augustine’s view, on grace, community, and disciplined habits. Absolutism without charity can harden into pride; moderation without vigilance dissolves into self-deception. The line holds best when it serves a larger love, training desire to seek what truly satisfies.
The insight grows out of Augustine’s own struggles. In the Confessions he prays, "Grant me chastity and continence, but not yet", revealing how desire bends the will even when reason knows the good. He diagnosed the human condition as marked by disordered loves and a divided will. In such a state, moderation is fragile because it relies on steady attention, stable desire, and consistent self-knowledge. Any lapse in clarity can tip moderation into excess. Abstinence, by contrast, simplifies the battlefield: the decision is made once, and the occasions of temptation are reduced.
This logic underlies ascetic practices in Christian tradition and finds echoes in modern psychology. Precommitment, bright-line rules, and minimization of decision fatigue are contemporary ways of saying that clear boundaries conserve moral energy. People who cannot drink just one drink often find sobriety more livable than perpetual micro-calibration. The same dynamic appears with gambling, pornography, or compulsive scrolling.
Yet Augustine is not exalting deprivation for its own sake. He affirms the goodness of creation and the virtue of temperance. The point is prudential: for fallen creatures, perfect moderation is the harder art, and failure can be ruinous. Abstinence becomes a strategy for reordering love and regaining freedom. There is also a warning here. What looks like sheer willpower depends, in Augustine’s view, on grace, community, and disciplined habits. Absolutism without charity can harden into pride; moderation without vigilance dissolves into self-deception. The line holds best when it serves a larger love, training desire to seek what truly satisfies.
Quote Details
| Topic | Self-Discipline |
|---|
More Quotes by Saint
Add to List
