"Conductors must give unmistakable and suggestive signals to the orchestra - not choreography to the audience"
About this Quote
Szell’s line lands like a slap at the cult of the maestro-as-celebrity: the conductor’s job is communication, not performance. “Unmistakable” is the key tell. He isn’t asking for inspiration in the abstract; he’s demanding clarity that survives adrenaline, bad acoustics, and the high-wire lag between gesture and sound. In that sense, the quote is less romantic than it is managerial: the podium is a command post, not a spotlight.
The jab at “choreography to the audience” carries Szell’s deeper subtext about modern spectatorship. As concert culture became increasingly visual - recordings, televised performances, glossy marketing, the iconic baton swoop - the conductor’s body risked turning into the main event. Szell, famously rigorous with the Cleveland Orchestra, is warning that a pretty silhouette can be musically useless, even harmful, if it seduces players into guessing rather than reading. Suggestive signals, in his vocabulary, aren’t vague; they’re cues that shape phrasing, color, attack, and tempo without drowning musicians in interpretive pantomime.
Context matters: Szell came up in a European tradition that prized precision and ensemble discipline, then enforced that standard in an American orchestral system increasingly tied to patrons, critics, and a public hungry for charisma. The line defends an older ethic: authority earns its keep by making others sound better. Anything else is theater masquerading as leadership.
The jab at “choreography to the audience” carries Szell’s deeper subtext about modern spectatorship. As concert culture became increasingly visual - recordings, televised performances, glossy marketing, the iconic baton swoop - the conductor’s body risked turning into the main event. Szell, famously rigorous with the Cleveland Orchestra, is warning that a pretty silhouette can be musically useless, even harmful, if it seduces players into guessing rather than reading. Suggestive signals, in his vocabulary, aren’t vague; they’re cues that shape phrasing, color, attack, and tempo without drowning musicians in interpretive pantomime.
Context matters: Szell came up in a European tradition that prized precision and ensemble discipline, then enforced that standard in an American orchestral system increasingly tied to patrons, critics, and a public hungry for charisma. The line defends an older ethic: authority earns its keep by making others sound better. Anything else is theater masquerading as leadership.
Quote Details
| Topic | Leadership |
|---|
More Quotes by George
Add to List



