"Creative without strategy is called 'art.' Creative with strategy is called 'advertising.'"
About this Quote
It flatters artists while quietly recruiting them. Richards draws a clean, quotable border between two worlds people love to keep separate: art as pure expression, advertising as calculated persuasion. The elegance is the trap. By reducing the difference to one variable - strategy - he reframes advertising not as a cynical downgrade of creativity, but as creativity with a job to do. In one sentence, he offers a professional ethic: don’t apologize for selling; just do it intelligently.
The subtext is a mild rebuke to the romantic myth that “real” creativity must be unplanned, instinctive, and unaccountable. Richards implies that undirected brilliance is culturally celebrated but economically irrelevant. Strategy, in this framing, isn’t a suit-and-tie constraint; it’s the thing that makes imagination legible to other people - measurable, repeatable, and tied to outcomes. That’s a professor talking: the world of briefs, objectives, audiences, and results.
Context matters because modern advertising has spent decades laundering its reputation through the language of art: cinematic brand films, award-show aesthetics, agencies styling themselves as studios. Richards reverses the laundering. He says the artistry was never the issue; intent was. Advertising isn’t “art that sold out.” It’s art designed from the start to move behavior, not just minds.
The line also smuggles in a warning. If strategy is what turns art into advertising, then bad strategy can turn good creativity into noise - or worse, manipulation. Richards isn’t just defining categories; he’s setting a standard: creativity deserves strategy not to tame it, but to aim it.
The subtext is a mild rebuke to the romantic myth that “real” creativity must be unplanned, instinctive, and unaccountable. Richards implies that undirected brilliance is culturally celebrated but economically irrelevant. Strategy, in this framing, isn’t a suit-and-tie constraint; it’s the thing that makes imagination legible to other people - measurable, repeatable, and tied to outcomes. That’s a professor talking: the world of briefs, objectives, audiences, and results.
Context matters because modern advertising has spent decades laundering its reputation through the language of art: cinematic brand films, award-show aesthetics, agencies styling themselves as studios. Richards reverses the laundering. He says the artistry was never the issue; intent was. Advertising isn’t “art that sold out.” It’s art designed from the start to move behavior, not just minds.
The line also smuggles in a warning. If strategy is what turns art into advertising, then bad strategy can turn good creativity into noise - or worse, manipulation. Richards isn’t just defining categories; he’s setting a standard: creativity deserves strategy not to tame it, but to aim it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Marketing |
|---|
More Quotes by Jef
Add to List
