"Critics are sentinels in the grand army of letters, stationed at the corners of newspapers and reviews, to challenge every new author"
About this Quote
Longfellow dresses the critic up as a guard on night watch, and the metaphor does a lot of quiet PR work. “Sentinels in the grand army of letters” turns literature into a disciplined campaign, not a parlor pastime, and it recasts criticism as public service: vigilance, duty, boundary-keeping. Stationed “at the corners of newspapers and reviews,” these figures aren’t high priests of taste; they’re posted where traffic flows, controlling the chokepoints of attention. The image flatters critics with importance while also hinting at their pettiness: corner sentries aren’t generals, and they don’t create the war they patrol.
The key verb is “challenge.” It sounds noble - rigorous testing, quality control - but it also implies suspicion as a default setting. “Every new author” is sweeping and faintly weary, suggesting a system designed to interrogate novelty before it can breathe. Longfellow is writing from a 19th-century literary marketplace where periodicals had become gatekeepers and reputations were made in print skirmishes. As a prominent poet who lived inside that machinery, he’s both legitimizing the critics’ role and registering the emotional toll of being perpetually inspected.
There’s subtext, too, about professionalization. Critics are not merely readers with opinions; they’re enlisted. That militarized framing lets Longfellow smuggle in a critique: when criticism becomes a standing army, it can start defending the institution more than the art - treating new writers as intruders to be challenged, not voices to be understood.
The key verb is “challenge.” It sounds noble - rigorous testing, quality control - but it also implies suspicion as a default setting. “Every new author” is sweeping and faintly weary, suggesting a system designed to interrogate novelty before it can breathe. Longfellow is writing from a 19th-century literary marketplace where periodicals had become gatekeepers and reputations were made in print skirmishes. As a prominent poet who lived inside that machinery, he’s both legitimizing the critics’ role and registering the emotional toll of being perpetually inspected.
There’s subtext, too, about professionalization. Critics are not merely readers with opinions; they’re enlisted. That militarized framing lets Longfellow smuggle in a critique: when criticism becomes a standing army, it can start defending the institution more than the art - treating new writers as intruders to be challenged, not voices to be understood.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Henry
Add to List
