"Cross cultural experience teaches us not simply that people have different beliefs, but that people seek meaning and understand themselves in some sense as members of a cosmos ruled by God"
About this Quote
Kirkpatrick’s line does a neat bit of diplomatic sleight of hand: it takes the polite multicultural lesson - “people have different beliefs” - and sharpens it into a claim about what beliefs are for. Difference isn’t a museum of customs; it’s a set of operating systems for making life intelligible. By insisting that people “seek meaning,” she nudges the listener away from the technocrat’s fantasy that politics can be reduced to interests, incentives, and data. Cultures don’t just disagree; they narrate existence.
The key pressure point is her phrase “members of a cosmos ruled by God.” It’s less an altar call than a warning label. In Kirkpatrick’s world - Cold War realism with a moral vocabulary - religion isn’t a private preference but a public architecture: it structures duty, authority, suffering, and belonging. To ignore that is to misread entire societies, then stumble into the kind of foreign-policy blunders that happen when American secular assumptions are treated as universal.
The subtext also pushes back against a certain liberal relativism. “Different beliefs” can sound like everything is negotiable. “Cosmos ruled by God” implies moral limits and sacred stakes, the kinds that don’t bend easily to diplomacy, development plans, or “modernization.” Coming from a diplomat, the intent is pragmatic: cross-cultural experience is not supposed to make you blandly tolerant; it’s supposed to make you strategically literate about what moves people.
In the late 20th-century context, the quote reads like an early memo for a post-Cold War world: ideology matters, but so do the metaphysical stories that survive every regime change.
The key pressure point is her phrase “members of a cosmos ruled by God.” It’s less an altar call than a warning label. In Kirkpatrick’s world - Cold War realism with a moral vocabulary - religion isn’t a private preference but a public architecture: it structures duty, authority, suffering, and belonging. To ignore that is to misread entire societies, then stumble into the kind of foreign-policy blunders that happen when American secular assumptions are treated as universal.
The subtext also pushes back against a certain liberal relativism. “Different beliefs” can sound like everything is negotiable. “Cosmos ruled by God” implies moral limits and sacred stakes, the kinds that don’t bend easily to diplomacy, development plans, or “modernization.” Coming from a diplomat, the intent is pragmatic: cross-cultural experience is not supposed to make you blandly tolerant; it’s supposed to make you strategically literate about what moves people.
In the late 20th-century context, the quote reads like an early memo for a post-Cold War world: ideology matters, but so do the metaphysical stories that survive every regime change.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Jeane
Add to List
