"David Lee Roth had the idea that if you covered a successful song, you were half way home. C'mon - Van Halen doing 'Dancing in the Streets'? It was stupid. I started feeling like I would rather bomb playing my own songs than be successful playing someone else's music"
About this Quote
Eddie Van Halen’s frustration lands like a power chord: virtuosity doesn’t mean much if you’re spending it on somebody else’s material. The swipe at David Lee Roth’s “half way home” logic isn’t just band drama; it’s a critique of a whole pop economy that treats recognition as the main instrument. A hit cover is a shortcut, a way to borrow cultural heat and cash it in fast. Eddie calls it “stupid” because it violates the ethic that made Van Halen feel dangerous in the first place: invention, risk, the thrill of hearing a new sound argue its way into the mainstream.
The choice of “Dancing in the Streets” matters. It’s not some obscure gem they’re rescuing; it’s a well-known Motown staple, already loaded with history and communal meaning. Dropping Van Halen’s high-gloss, high-voltage sheen onto it can read like a brand exercise: proof the machine can “Van Halen-ize” anything. Eddie hears that as dilution, not versatility.
Then he delivers the artist’s ultimate heresy against the industry: “I would rather bomb.” That line is a moral claim disguised as a career move. Failure, in his framing, is at least honest feedback from the world; success with borrowed songs is counterfeit validation. In the background is the late-’70s/early-’80s rock marketplace, where labels loved safe bets and MTV rewarded instant familiarity. Eddie’s subtext: I didn’t build this guitar language to be a jukebox. I built it to say something only we could say.
The choice of “Dancing in the Streets” matters. It’s not some obscure gem they’re rescuing; it’s a well-known Motown staple, already loaded with history and communal meaning. Dropping Van Halen’s high-gloss, high-voltage sheen onto it can read like a brand exercise: proof the machine can “Van Halen-ize” anything. Eddie hears that as dilution, not versatility.
Then he delivers the artist’s ultimate heresy against the industry: “I would rather bomb.” That line is a moral claim disguised as a career move. Failure, in his framing, is at least honest feedback from the world; success with borrowed songs is counterfeit validation. In the background is the late-’70s/early-’80s rock marketplace, where labels loved safe bets and MTV rewarded instant familiarity. Eddie’s subtext: I didn’t build this guitar language to be a jukebox. I built it to say something only we could say.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Eddie
Add to List
