"Decisions! And a general, a commander in chief who has not got the quality of decision, then he is no good"
About this Quote
"Decisions!" lands like a barked order because Montgomery is selling a theory of command that’s less about brilliance than nerve. The exclamation point matters: it’s not a reflective maxim, it’s battlefield punctuation. In his world, hesitation is not a personality quirk; it’s a casualty multiplier.
Montgomery’s intent is bluntly instructional, almost disciplinary. A commander in chief who can’t decide is "no good" because command is the job of converting incomplete information into coherent action. War punishes the fantasy of perfect clarity. You choose a course, you impose tempo, and you force the enemy to react to you rather than the other way around. The line also protects hierarchy: if the top cannot decide, every layer beneath starts freelancing, second-guessing, or freezing. Indecision doesn’t stay at the top; it leaks down the chain of command.
The subtext is equally self-justifying. Montgomery cultivated a public persona of certainty, and certainty is a weapon in itself: it steadies troops, reassures politicians, and broadcasts inevitability to opponents. Calling decision the defining quality of leadership reframes controversy about strategy as a moral test of character. You’re not debating plans; you’re measuring mettle.
Contextually, this comes out of a 20th-century command culture forged in mass war, where delay could mean encirclement, supply collapse, or squandered advantage. It’s also a postwar lesson for peacetime bureaucracies: committees can disperse responsibility, but battle concentrates it. Montgomery’s warning isn’t that mistakes are unforgivable; it’s that paralysis is.
Montgomery’s intent is bluntly instructional, almost disciplinary. A commander in chief who can’t decide is "no good" because command is the job of converting incomplete information into coherent action. War punishes the fantasy of perfect clarity. You choose a course, you impose tempo, and you force the enemy to react to you rather than the other way around. The line also protects hierarchy: if the top cannot decide, every layer beneath starts freelancing, second-guessing, or freezing. Indecision doesn’t stay at the top; it leaks down the chain of command.
The subtext is equally self-justifying. Montgomery cultivated a public persona of certainty, and certainty is a weapon in itself: it steadies troops, reassures politicians, and broadcasts inevitability to opponents. Calling decision the defining quality of leadership reframes controversy about strategy as a moral test of character. You’re not debating plans; you’re measuring mettle.
Contextually, this comes out of a 20th-century command culture forged in mass war, where delay could mean encirclement, supply collapse, or squandered advantage. It’s also a postwar lesson for peacetime bureaucracies: committees can disperse responsibility, but battle concentrates it. Montgomery’s warning isn’t that mistakes are unforgivable; it’s that paralysis is.
Quote Details
| Topic | Decision-Making |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Bernard
Add to List






