"Devout believers are safeguarded in a high degree against the risk of certain neurotic illnesses; their acceptance of the universal neurosis spares them the task of constructing a personal one"
About this Quote
There is a gleeful sting in the way France frames faith as a kind of psychological group plan: sign up for the “universal neurosis” and you won’t have to DIY your own. The line works because it refuses to flatter either side. Belief isn’t dismissed as mere ignorance, but reclassified as an efficient coping structure: a ready-made narrative, a sanctioned ritual schedule, a moral logic that can metabolize anxiety into meaning. The provocation isn’t “religion is false,” but “religion is functional,” which is a more unsettling charge for a culture that wants faith to be either sacred truth or backward error.
The subtext is social as much as clinical. “Safeguarded” hints at insurance, architecture, fortification: religion as an institution that distributes psychic risk across a community. France’s pivot from “certain neurotic illnesses” to “personal one” suggests that what modernity produces is not enlightenment but loneliness - the burden of inventing private explanations for dread, guilt, desire, death. In that light, devotion looks less like delusion than relief: your suffering gets a script, your contradictions get a confessor, your fear gets an afterlife.
Context matters: France writes from the anticlerical, late-19th-century French intelligentsia, where the church was both moral authority and political machinery. His novelist’s eye catches the bargain: dogma can be constraining, but it’s also a pre-packaged interior life. The irony lands because it implicates the secular reader too: if you reject the communal myth, you still have to build something to stand in its place, and not everyone is a sturdy architect of the self.
The subtext is social as much as clinical. “Safeguarded” hints at insurance, architecture, fortification: religion as an institution that distributes psychic risk across a community. France’s pivot from “certain neurotic illnesses” to “personal one” suggests that what modernity produces is not enlightenment but loneliness - the burden of inventing private explanations for dread, guilt, desire, death. In that light, devotion looks less like delusion than relief: your suffering gets a script, your contradictions get a confessor, your fear gets an afterlife.
Context matters: France writes from the anticlerical, late-19th-century French intelligentsia, where the church was both moral authority and political machinery. His novelist’s eye catches the bargain: dogma can be constraining, but it’s also a pre-packaged interior life. The irony lands because it implicates the secular reader too: if you reject the communal myth, you still have to build something to stand in its place, and not everyone is a sturdy architect of the self.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Anatole
Add to List



