"Dialogue should simply be a sound among other sounds, just something that comes out of the mouths of people whose eyes tell the story in visual terms"
About this Quote
Hitchcock is basically demoting dialogue from king to foley. In that little word "simply" you can hear the director’s lifelong impatience with the literary prestige of movies: if film is reduced to people explaining themselves, it becomes photographed theater, a medium wearing someone else’s clothes. He wants speech to sit in the mix the way footsteps or a distant train does - texture, timing, misdirection - while the real information lives in faces, glances, and blocking.
The subtext is control. Dialogue is slippery; actors can overemote it, writers can over-clarify it, audiences can cling to it as a crib sheet. Eyes are harder to counterfeit and easier to choreograph. Hitchcock’s cinema runs on the tension between what characters say and what the camera knows. Let them talk, sure, but let the image contradict them. The mouth offers alibis; the eyes leak the truth. That’s not anti-writing so much as anti-explanation.
Context matters: Hitchcock comes out of silent film, where visual grammar had to carry narrative without verbal handrails, and he arrives in the talkie era wary of how quickly sound could turn movies into radio with pictures. His set pieces - the stairwell, the shower, the crop duster - are engineered to be legible with the volume off. Dialogue becomes another instrument for suspense: it can soothe, distract, or lie while the frame quietly assembles dread. In Hitchcock’s hands, the most honest line is often the one nobody speaks.
The subtext is control. Dialogue is slippery; actors can overemote it, writers can over-clarify it, audiences can cling to it as a crib sheet. Eyes are harder to counterfeit and easier to choreograph. Hitchcock’s cinema runs on the tension between what characters say and what the camera knows. Let them talk, sure, but let the image contradict them. The mouth offers alibis; the eyes leak the truth. That’s not anti-writing so much as anti-explanation.
Context matters: Hitchcock comes out of silent film, where visual grammar had to carry narrative without verbal handrails, and he arrives in the talkie era wary of how quickly sound could turn movies into radio with pictures. His set pieces - the stairwell, the shower, the crop duster - are engineered to be legible with the volume off. Dialogue becomes another instrument for suspense: it can soothe, distract, or lie while the frame quietly assembles dread. In Hitchcock’s hands, the most honest line is often the one nobody speaks.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|
More Quotes by Alfred
Add to List



