"Do not allow yourself to imagine that revolutionary thinking can be propagated by governmental power"
About this Quote
Bhave’s warning lands like a gentle slap at the reformer’s favorite fantasy: that you can legislate a new mind. “Revolutionary thinking” isn’t just a policy platform; it’s an inner reorientation, the kind that can’t be mass-produced by decree without becoming its opposite. The line is aimed at the well-meaning modernizer who treats the state as a moral megaphone. Bhave is saying: the megaphone distorts.
The subtext is a critique of power’s gravitational pull. Government can compel behavior, redistribute goods, punish dissent, even engineer incentives that mimic conviction. What it can’t do is manufacture the voluntary moral leap that makes a revolution worth more than a regime change. When the state takes charge of “propagating” ideas, belief starts to look like compliance, and dissent becomes not just disagreement but disloyalty. That’s how revolutions fossilize into orthodoxies.
Context matters: Bhave emerged from Gandhi’s ethical tradition, suspicious of coercion even in the service of justice. His Bhoodan (land-gift) movement depended on persuasion, shame, conscience, and community pressure rather than legal expropriation. In postcolonial India, where the new state promised development and social transformation, he’s pushing back against the seductive notion that independence automatically authorizes social engineering from above.
The quote works because it refuses both cynicism and naivete. It doesn’t deny government’s role in changing conditions; it insists that changing consciousness is a different category of work. Revolutionary thinking, in Bhave’s frame, spreads the old-fashioned way: through example, sacrifice, and the slow contagion of lived integrity.
The subtext is a critique of power’s gravitational pull. Government can compel behavior, redistribute goods, punish dissent, even engineer incentives that mimic conviction. What it can’t do is manufacture the voluntary moral leap that makes a revolution worth more than a regime change. When the state takes charge of “propagating” ideas, belief starts to look like compliance, and dissent becomes not just disagreement but disloyalty. That’s how revolutions fossilize into orthodoxies.
Context matters: Bhave emerged from Gandhi’s ethical tradition, suspicious of coercion even in the service of justice. His Bhoodan (land-gift) movement depended on persuasion, shame, conscience, and community pressure rather than legal expropriation. In postcolonial India, where the new state promised development and social transformation, he’s pushing back against the seductive notion that independence automatically authorizes social engineering from above.
The quote works because it refuses both cynicism and naivete. It doesn’t deny government’s role in changing conditions; it insists that changing consciousness is a different category of work. Revolutionary thinking, in Bhave’s frame, spreads the old-fashioned way: through example, sacrifice, and the slow contagion of lived integrity.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Vinoba
Add to List
