"Don't learn to do, but learn in doing. Let your falls not be on a prepared ground, but let them be bona fide falls in the rough and tumble of the world"
About this Quote
Butler is picking a fight with the Victorian fantasy of competence-by-theory: the idea that you can read your way into adulthood, rehearse your way into bravery, and emerge into life already polished. "Don't learn to do" is a deliberately awkward provocation, almost a verbal stumble, because he wants to trip the reader out of the tidy grammar of self-improvement. The real target is preparation as a substitute for experience: training wheels mistaken for the bicycle.
"Learn in doing" flips learning from a preliminary hurdle into the main event. It is a protest against protected environments - the "prepared ground" of classrooms, moral instruction, and genteel society - that promise safety at the cost of reality. Butler's subtext is not anti-intellectual; it's anti-simulated. He distrusts any education that lets you fail without consequence, because consequence is where the lesson has teeth.
The second sentence sharpens into a kind of bruising pedagogy. "Falls" are not metaphors for mild setbacks; they are the price of agency. "Bona fide falls" in the "rough and tumble of the world" insists on authenticity over hygiene: mistakes that can actually embarrass you, cost you, change you. That phrase also punctures Victorian respectability, with its obsession with appearing correct. Butler suggests that a life spent avoiding real falls is its own failure - immaculate, rehearsed, and fundamentally untested.
Context matters: Butler, a poet and skeptic of institutional authority, lived amid an era industrializing everything, including education and virtue. His line reads like an early warning against credentialism and curated risk - and a dare to trade perfect plans for imperfect contact with the real.
"Learn in doing" flips learning from a preliminary hurdle into the main event. It is a protest against protected environments - the "prepared ground" of classrooms, moral instruction, and genteel society - that promise safety at the cost of reality. Butler's subtext is not anti-intellectual; it's anti-simulated. He distrusts any education that lets you fail without consequence, because consequence is where the lesson has teeth.
The second sentence sharpens into a kind of bruising pedagogy. "Falls" are not metaphors for mild setbacks; they are the price of agency. "Bona fide falls" in the "rough and tumble of the world" insists on authenticity over hygiene: mistakes that can actually embarrass you, cost you, change you. That phrase also punctures Victorian respectability, with its obsession with appearing correct. Butler suggests that a life spent avoiding real falls is its own failure - immaculate, rehearsed, and fundamentally untested.
Context matters: Butler, a poet and skeptic of institutional authority, lived amid an era industrializing everything, including education and virtue. His line reads like an early warning against credentialism and curated risk - and a dare to trade perfect plans for imperfect contact with the real.
Quote Details
| Topic | Learning from Mistakes |
|---|
More Quotes by Samuel
Add to List
