"Don't take the will for the deed; get the deed"
About this Quote
Mumford’s line is a scalpel aimed at a modern habit: treating intention as a moral substitute for action. “Don’t take the will for the deed” sounds almost biblical in its cadence, but it’s really an anti-alibi. The phrase “the will” names that warm, self-flattering zone where we feel virtuous for wanting to do the right thing, or for applauding the right outcomes, without paying the cost of making them real. Mumford won’t even grant it the dignity of a partial credit. He calls it what it often becomes in public life: a counterfeit.
The second clause sharpens the blade. “Get the deed” isn’t “do the deed,” which would center individual grit. “Get” implies systems, procurement, organization, follow-through. It’s a sociologist’s verb, not a self-help coach’s. Deeds have to be produced under real constraints: institutions, incentives, planning, power. Mumford spent his career diagnosing how societies congratulate themselves on “progress” while building cities and technologies that quietly corrode community and human scale. In that context, the line reads like a warning label on modernity: aspiration is cheap; infrastructure is destiny.
The subtext is impatience with performative morality and symbolic politics, the sort that thrives on declarations, manifestos, and “raising awareness” while roads, housing, schools, and public health rot. Mumford’s wit is in the bluntness: if you want a humane society, stop collecting good intentions like virtue points. Secure outcomes. Build them.
The second clause sharpens the blade. “Get the deed” isn’t “do the deed,” which would center individual grit. “Get” implies systems, procurement, organization, follow-through. It’s a sociologist’s verb, not a self-help coach’s. Deeds have to be produced under real constraints: institutions, incentives, planning, power. Mumford spent his career diagnosing how societies congratulate themselves on “progress” while building cities and technologies that quietly corrode community and human scale. In that context, the line reads like a warning label on modernity: aspiration is cheap; infrastructure is destiny.
The subtext is impatience with performative morality and symbolic politics, the sort that thrives on declarations, manifestos, and “raising awareness” while roads, housing, schools, and public health rot. Mumford’s wit is in the bluntness: if you want a humane society, stop collecting good intentions like virtue points. Secure outcomes. Build them.
Quote Details
| Topic | Motivational |
|---|
More Quotes by Lewis
Add to List











