"Drunkenness is temporary suicide"
About this Quote
Russell’s line lands like a courtroom definition: spare, prosecutorial, designed to strip booze of its romantic costume. “Temporary suicide” is a deliberately scandalous pairing, not because it’s literally precise but because it forces a moral and psychological reclassification. Drunkenness isn’t framed as play, release, or even “vice” in the old-fashioned sense; it’s a rehearsal for self-erasure, a chosen interval of non-being. The wit is Russell’s: he compresses a whole ethical argument into an equation, then lets the shock do the work.
The subtext is less temperance-pamphlet than Enlightenment anxiety. Russell, a philosopher of clarity and self-command, treats consciousness as the seat of agency. If you voluntarily switch it off, you’re not just breaking rules; you’re abdicating responsibility, outsourcing the self. “Temporary” is the needle: it admits the drinker’s defense (I’ll be fine tomorrow) while exposing the impulse underneath (I want to not be me for a while). That’s a bleak diagnosis of modern life: not sin, but escape.
Context matters. Russell lived through industrial modernity, world wars, and the mechanization of daily existence. In that landscape, intoxication can look like a small personal mutiny. Russell refuses to grant it that dignity. By calling it suicide, he recasts the act as self-directed violence masked as leisure, a private collapse sold as a night out. It’s not moral panic; it’s philosophical triage: if your relief requires erasing your mind, the problem isn’t the party.
The subtext is less temperance-pamphlet than Enlightenment anxiety. Russell, a philosopher of clarity and self-command, treats consciousness as the seat of agency. If you voluntarily switch it off, you’re not just breaking rules; you’re abdicating responsibility, outsourcing the self. “Temporary” is the needle: it admits the drinker’s defense (I’ll be fine tomorrow) while exposing the impulse underneath (I want to not be me for a while). That’s a bleak diagnosis of modern life: not sin, but escape.
Context matters. Russell lived through industrial modernity, world wars, and the mechanization of daily existence. In that landscape, intoxication can look like a small personal mutiny. Russell refuses to grant it that dignity. By calling it suicide, he recasts the act as self-directed violence masked as leisure, a private collapse sold as a night out. It’s not moral panic; it’s philosophical triage: if your relief requires erasing your mind, the problem isn’t the party.
Quote Details
| Topic | Health |
|---|
More Quotes by Bertrand
Add to List








