"During war, the laws are silent"
About this Quote
A brutal little sentence that pretends to be an observation and smuggles in a warning. "During war, the laws are silent" frames violence not just as chaos, but as a force that mutes the very machinery meant to restrain power. It works because it’s blunt enough to sound like common sense while quietly posing a moral dilemma: if law goes quiet when it’s most needed, what exactly is it for?
Cicero knew the Roman Republic at the moment when emergency powers were becoming a habit and legality was being treated as a luxury item. The line is usually read as a defense of necessity, the idea that existential threat authorizes extraordinary measures. But the subtext cuts both ways. By personifying laws as "silent", Cicero hints that law isn’t some eternal constant; it’s a human institution that depends on consent, enforcement, and political courage. War doesn’t simply break rules, it breaks the conditions that allow rules to function.
The intent is strategic: to normalize how war reshuffles priorities, and to create rhetorical cover for leaders who act first and justify later. Yet it also exposes the danger of that logic. Once you accept that war suspends law, every ambitious politician has an incentive to describe their moment as wartime. Rome’s late-republic politics ran on that move: crisis language as a solvent for accountability.
Calling Cicero a "soldier" misses the point. He’s the republic’s lawyer-critic, describing how power talks when law can’t.
Cicero knew the Roman Republic at the moment when emergency powers were becoming a habit and legality was being treated as a luxury item. The line is usually read as a defense of necessity, the idea that existential threat authorizes extraordinary measures. But the subtext cuts both ways. By personifying laws as "silent", Cicero hints that law isn’t some eternal constant; it’s a human institution that depends on consent, enforcement, and political courage. War doesn’t simply break rules, it breaks the conditions that allow rules to function.
The intent is strategic: to normalize how war reshuffles priorities, and to create rhetorical cover for leaders who act first and justify later. Yet it also exposes the danger of that logic. Once you accept that war suspends law, every ambitious politician has an incentive to describe their moment as wartime. Rome’s late-republic politics ran on that move: crisis language as a solvent for accountability.
Calling Cicero a "soldier" misses the point. He’s the republic’s lawyer-critic, describing how power talks when law can’t.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Quintus
Add to List
