"Each age tries to form its own conception of the past. Each age writes the history of the past anew with reference to the conditions uppermost in its own time"
About this Quote
Turner is handing you a warning disguised as a method. History, in his telling, is not a vault you unlock once and walk away from; its contents get rearranged every time the present changes its priorities. The line works because it’s both descriptive and subtly accusatory: if “each age” rewrites the past, then any confident, final story about national origins is already suspect, less discovery than design.
The intent is partly disciplinary. Turner, a founding figure of American historiography, is staking a claim for why professional historians matter: not to freeze the past in amber, but to disclose the pressures that make certain narratives feel inevitable in one era and ridiculous in another. His famous frontier thesis (1893) argued that American democracy and character were forged at the expanding edge of settlement, and he delivered it right as the U.S. declared the frontier “closed” and the country lurched into industrial capitalism, labor unrest, and overseas ambition. That timing isn’t incidental. When the physical frontier disappears, the nation reaches for an interpretive one.
The subtext is a quiet rebuttal to naïve objectivity and to political mythmaking alike. Turner is conceding that history is conditioned by present needs, then insisting that the honest move is to name those needs rather than pretend they don’t exist. Read now, it lands as an early diagnosis of today’s “history wars”: the past as a contested resource, constantly re-edited to authorize current power, identity, and policy.
The intent is partly disciplinary. Turner, a founding figure of American historiography, is staking a claim for why professional historians matter: not to freeze the past in amber, but to disclose the pressures that make certain narratives feel inevitable in one era and ridiculous in another. His famous frontier thesis (1893) argued that American democracy and character were forged at the expanding edge of settlement, and he delivered it right as the U.S. declared the frontier “closed” and the country lurched into industrial capitalism, labor unrest, and overseas ambition. That timing isn’t incidental. When the physical frontier disappears, the nation reaches for an interpretive one.
The subtext is a quiet rebuttal to naïve objectivity and to political mythmaking alike. Turner is conceding that history is conditioned by present needs, then insisting that the honest move is to name those needs rather than pretend they don’t exist. Read now, it lands as an early diagnosis of today’s “history wars”: the past as a contested resource, constantly re-edited to authorize current power, identity, and policy.
Quote Details
| Topic | Time |
|---|
More Quotes by Frederick
Add to List
