"Education is a private matter between the person and the world of knowledge and experience, and has little to do with school or college"
About this Quote
Smith’s line is a polite sentence with a provocation tucked inside: it steals education back from the institutions that claim to dispense it. Calling it “a private matter” reframes learning as something intimate and self-directed, more like a moral awakening or a slow unlearning than a credential. The “world of knowledge and experience” is doing double duty here. Knowledge suggests books, ideas, history; experience suggests the messy, embodied realities schools often sanitize. Put together, they imply that real education happens when a person collides with the world as it is, not just as it’s packaged.
The subtext carries a sharper edge. If education “has little to do with school or college,” then schools are exposed as secondary actors: gatekeepers, sorting machines, sometimes even distractions. Smith isn’t anti-intellectual; she’s anti-complacency. She’s warning against confusing attendance with understanding, grades with judgment, institutional approval with genuine growth.
Context matters because Smith wrote as a Southern novelist and outspoken critic of segregation, someone who watched “education” used as a civic ornament while ignorance was enforced as policy. In that light, her insistence on privacy isn’t about retreating into individualism; it’s about reclaiming agency in a culture where public institutions could be compromised by power. The intent is almost insurgent: if schools won’t tell the truth, the person must pursue it anyway. Education becomes not a place you go, but a stance you take.
The subtext carries a sharper edge. If education “has little to do with school or college,” then schools are exposed as secondary actors: gatekeepers, sorting machines, sometimes even distractions. Smith isn’t anti-intellectual; she’s anti-complacency. She’s warning against confusing attendance with understanding, grades with judgment, institutional approval with genuine growth.
Context matters because Smith wrote as a Southern novelist and outspoken critic of segregation, someone who watched “education” used as a civic ornament while ignorance was enforced as policy. In that light, her insistence on privacy isn’t about retreating into individualism; it’s about reclaiming agency in a culture where public institutions could be compromised by power. The intent is almost insurgent: if schools won’t tell the truth, the person must pursue it anyway. Education becomes not a place you go, but a stance you take.
Quote Details
| Topic | Learning |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: Wisdom for the Soul (Larry Chang, 2006) modern compilationISBN: 9780977339105 · ID: -T3QhPjIxhIC
Evidence: ... Education is a private matter between the person and the world of knowledge and experience , and has little to do with school or college . ~ Lillian Smith , 1897-1966 ~ The world of learning is so broad , and the human soul so limited ... Other candidates (1) Aristotle (Lillian Smith) compilation37.5% re knowable are ambiguous terms for there is a difference between what is prior and more knowable in the order of bei... |
More Quotes by Lillian
Add to List








