"Either war is obsolete, or men are"
About this Quote
A clean little guillotine of a sentence: if war belongs to the future, then maybe humans don’t. Fuller frames the dilemma as a binary not because he can’t imagine nuance, but because he wants to corner the reader into admitting what modernity has already made obscene. In an age where industrialization turned slaughter into logistics and the nuclear horizon made “winning” feel like a bookkeeping trick, “war” stops looking like a tragic inevitability and starts looking like a design failure.
That’s Fuller’s signature move: treat civilization as a system you can debug. The line isn’t moral pleading; it’s engineering rhetoric dressed as aphorism. “Obsolete” is a word from tool sheds and patents, not pulpits. It implies replacement. If war is outdated, it’s because we’ve built (or could build) better mechanisms for conflict: institutions, interdependence, information, abundance-by-design. If men are obsolete, the indictment is harsher: a species unable to update its operating system in response to new hardware.
The subtext is a Cold War dare. Fuller’s lifetime runs from horse-drawn armies to ICBMs, from scarcity economics to mass production. He’s telling his era that evolution is no longer slow and natural; it’s technological and sudden. Either we retire war like we retired the musket, or we’ll retire ourselves. The brilliance is how he makes that threat sound like common sense.
That’s Fuller’s signature move: treat civilization as a system you can debug. The line isn’t moral pleading; it’s engineering rhetoric dressed as aphorism. “Obsolete” is a word from tool sheds and patents, not pulpits. It implies replacement. If war is outdated, it’s because we’ve built (or could build) better mechanisms for conflict: institutions, interdependence, information, abundance-by-design. If men are obsolete, the indictment is harsher: a species unable to update its operating system in response to new hardware.
The subtext is a Cold War dare. Fuller’s lifetime runs from horse-drawn armies to ICBMs, from scarcity economics to mass production. He’s telling his era that evolution is no longer slow and natural; it’s technological and sudden. Either we retire war like we retired the musket, or we’ll retire ourselves. The brilliance is how he makes that threat sound like common sense.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Buckminster Fuller
Add to List










