"Either you repeat the same conventional doctrines everybody is saying, or else you say something true, and it will sound like it's from Neptune"
About this Quote
Chomsky is describing a rigged acoustics problem: in a tightly managed public sphere, truth doesn’t arrive as illumination, it arrives as dissonance. The line turns on a bleak joke. “Conventional doctrines” aren’t just popular opinions; they’re the pre-approved scripts that let you sound reasonable on cue. Step outside them and you don’t merely become “controversial” - you become unintelligible, as if you’re broadcasting from “Neptune.” The planet is doing cultural work here: it marks the distance between lived reality and what the mainstream is prepared to hear.
The intent is less to flatter the brave truth-teller than to indict the audience and the machinery that trains it. Chomsky’s subtext is that mass media, institutional incentives, and political orthodoxy don’t only police ideas through censorship; they accomplish something subtler by shaping what registers as “common sense.” When that baseline shifts, accurate descriptions can sound like conspiracy, extremism, or naive idealism. The listener’s ear has been tuned to recognize repetition as credibility.
Contextually, this fits Chomsky’s long-running critique of manufactured consent: a system that doesn’t need to ban dissent if it can make dissent socially expensive and cognitively alien. The quote’s sting is that it normalizes the loneliness of stating the obvious. If you find yourself sounding like you’re from Neptune, Chomsky implies, that’s not proof you’re wrong. It may be evidence that the atmosphere here has been engineered for echo, not oxygen.
The intent is less to flatter the brave truth-teller than to indict the audience and the machinery that trains it. Chomsky’s subtext is that mass media, institutional incentives, and political orthodoxy don’t only police ideas through censorship; they accomplish something subtler by shaping what registers as “common sense.” When that baseline shifts, accurate descriptions can sound like conspiracy, extremism, or naive idealism. The listener’s ear has been tuned to recognize repetition as credibility.
Contextually, this fits Chomsky’s long-running critique of manufactured consent: a system that doesn’t need to ban dissent if it can make dissent socially expensive and cognitively alien. The quote’s sting is that it normalizes the loneliness of stating the obvious. If you find yourself sounding like you’re from Neptune, Chomsky implies, that’s not proof you’re wrong. It may be evidence that the atmosphere here has been engineered for echo, not oxygen.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Noam
Add to List





