Art & Creativity Quote by Dorothy Fields

"Elizabeth Barrett Browning could write a poem two pages long. Could she have brought it to a music publisher?"

Dorothy Fields, Musician

About this Quote

Fields lands the punch with a name-drop: Elizabeth Barrett Browning, the high priestess of serious, book-length feeling, gets held up against the blunt economics of Tin Pan Alley. The joke isn’t that Browning lacked talent; it’s that “talent” is the wrong currency in a business built around sellable units. Two pages of poetry reads like grandeur. Two pages of lyrics looks like a problem.

The intent is both defense and critique. Fields is implicitly arguing for the craft of the popular song, where compression isn’t a concession but the whole game: character, plot, hook, and heartbreak inside a structure a band can play and an audience can remember on the walk home. At the same time, she’s skewering the gatekeepers who treat art as inventory. “Could she have brought it to a music publisher?” isn’t a question about aesthetics; it’s about whether the system can even process work that doesn’t fit its formats.

Subtext: the songwriter’s perpetual double bind. If you write too “literary,” you’re impractical. If you write too cleanly for commerce, you’re dismissed as lightweight. Fields, a woman who thrived in an industry that often trivialized what women wrote and performed, flips the hierarchy. She doesn’t beg poetry for validation; she dares poetry to survive the marketplace test she knows intimately.

Context matters: Fields wrote in an era when songs were manufactured for Broadway, film, and radio, where publishers, performers, and runtime limits ruled. Her line is a sly professional flex: art isn’t only what you can feel; it’s what you can deliver.

Quote Details

Topic	Poetry
Source	Help us find the source
Cite

More Quotes by Dorothy Add to List

About the Author

Dorothy Fields

Dorothy Fields (July 15, 1905 - March 28, 1974) was a Musician from USA.

18 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

"I entirely agree with you about the obscurity of Mrs Browning's line about the stars. It is far-fetched. She wanted to express something which she found beyond expression"

Marie Corelli, Novelist

"That's a wonderful change that's taken place, and so most poetry today is published, if not directly by the person, certainly by the enterprise of the poet himself, working with his friends"

A. R. Ammons, Poet

"I was in Paris at an English-language bookstore. I picked up a volume of Dickinson's poetry. I came back to my hotel, read 2,000 of her poems and immediately began composing in my head. I wrote down the melodies even before I got to a piano"

Gordon Getty, Businessman

"I'm a commercial writer, not an author. Margaret Mitchell was an author. She wrote one book"

Mickey Spillane, Author

"I am still interested in the long or serial poem, but have written a few smaller things. I may start sending to journals again in a year or so... that's about it"

George Murray, Poet

"My readers at that time were still men of letters; but there had to be other people waiting to read my poems"

Salvatore Quasimodo, Author

"The title of the poems was The Only Bar in Dixon. We sent it out to The New Yorker on a fluke, and they took them and printed all three in the same issue"

James Welch, Writer

"Our most famous writers are Faulkner and Eudora Welty and Flannery O'Connor. It would make sense that the poetry would reflect some of those same values, some of the same techniques"

Robert Morgan, Soldier

Robert Morgan

"Writing a book of poetry is like dropping a rose petal down the Grand Canyon and waiting for the echo"

Don Marquis, Journalist

Don Marquis

"I wonder if I ever thought of an ideal reader... I guess when I was in my 20s and in New York and maybe even in my early 30s, I would write for my wife Janice... mainly for my poet friends and my wife, who was very smart about poetry"

Kenneth Koch, Poet

"I think that there are fiction writers for whom that works well. I could never do it. I feel as if, by the time I see that it's a poem, it's almost written in my head somewhere"

Sharon Olds, Poet

"My mother carried on and supported us; her ambition had been to write poetry and songs"

Philip Levine, Poet

"I wrote poems in my corner of the Brooks Street station. I sent them to two editors who rejected them right off. I read those letters of rejection years later and I agreed with those editors"

Carl Sandburg, Poet

Carl Sandburg

"A great many people seem to think writing poetry is worthwhile, even though it pays next to nothing and is not as widely read as it should be"

Mark Strand, Poet

"When I became more involved in music, I had to give up some of my writing in the literary sense. However, on occasion, I would write something for my own pleasure or I would write notes and introductory remarks in the songbooks I put together"

Tom Glazer, Musician

Tom Glazer

"Poets lose half the praise they should have got, Could it be known what they discreetly blot"

Edmund Waller, Poet

"What she did was to open our eyes to details of country life such as teaching us names of wild flowers and getting us to draw and paint and learn poetry"

Laurie Lee, Poet

"That poetry survived in its formal agencies finally, and that prose survived to get something said"

Robert Creeley, Poet

"A poet's autobiography is his poetry. Anything else is just a footnote"

Yevgeny Yevtushenko, Poet

Yevgeny Yevtushenko

"One can't write for all readers. A poet cannot write for people who don't like poetry"

Nathalie Sarraute, Lawyer