"Emotion resulting from a work of art is only of value when it is not obtained by sentimental blackmail"
About this Quote
Cocteau draws a hard line between being moved and being manipulated, and he does it with the cool severity of someone who’s watched audiences confuse tears with truth. “Sentimental blackmail” is the knife twist: it suggests a transaction, not an encounter. The artwork doesn’t invite feeling; it extorts it, yanking predictable levers (orphaned children, swelling strings, moral simplifications) until the viewer pays up in emotion. Cocteau isn’t anti-feeling. He’s anti-cheap feeling, the kind that flatters us for having it.
The intent is aesthetic but also ethical. In Cocteau’s world - where modernism is trying to break from bourgeois taste and cinema is still proving it can be more than illustrated theater - sentimentality looks like a con job. It offers instant catharsis without risk, complexity, or ambiguity. His phrasing makes “value” contingent: emotion matters only when it arrives as a byproduct of form, image, rhythm, and insight, not as the prepackaged goal.
Subtext: the artist’s job is to craft conditions for discovery, not to pre-decide the audience’s response. Blackmail replaces agency with coercion; it tells you what to feel and congratulates itself when you comply. That’s why the line still lands in an age of prestige content and algorithmic “tearjerker” beats. Cocteau is warning that when art aims primarily to be “moving,” it often settles for being merely effective - and effectiveness can be the enemy of honesty.
The intent is aesthetic but also ethical. In Cocteau’s world - where modernism is trying to break from bourgeois taste and cinema is still proving it can be more than illustrated theater - sentimentality looks like a con job. It offers instant catharsis without risk, complexity, or ambiguity. His phrasing makes “value” contingent: emotion matters only when it arrives as a byproduct of form, image, rhythm, and insight, not as the prepackaged goal.
Subtext: the artist’s job is to craft conditions for discovery, not to pre-decide the audience’s response. Blackmail replaces agency with coercion; it tells you what to feel and congratulates itself when you comply. That’s why the line still lands in an age of prestige content and algorithmic “tearjerker” beats. Cocteau is warning that when art aims primarily to be “moving,” it often settles for being merely effective - and effectiveness can be the enemy of honesty.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Jean
Add to List






