"Entrenched scriptural literalism is, in my opinion, completely out of touch with reality"
About this Quote
Calling scriptural literalism "entrenched" is the tell: Malcolm Boyd isn’t picking a fight with faith so much as with the institutional reflex to freeze it. The word does double duty, suggesting both longevity and stubbornness - belief calcified into policy, sermon, and social boundary. By adding "in my opinion", Boyd adopts a pastoral posture rather than a prosecutorial one. It’s a cleric’s way of lighting a match while still sounding like he’s offering a hand.
"Completely out of touch with reality" lands as a moral and practical indictment. Reality here isn’t just science or modern history; it’s lived experience - the messy evidence of people’s lives refusing to fit a tidy proof-text. Boyd’s subtext is that literalism often functions less as reverence and more as control: a method for shutting down ambiguity, debate, and the discomfort that comes with changing social norms. Literalism reads as certainty, but Boyd implies it’s actually avoidance.
Context matters: Boyd’s career sits in the long 20th-century struggle within American Christianity over modernity, civil rights, sexuality, and the authority of religious institutions. Clergy like Boyd pushed for a faith that could meet the contemporary world without surrendering its spiritual core. The line is crafted to pierce a particular bubble - communities where "the Bible says" ends conversation - by reframing the issue as a failure of contact, not a failure of devotion. The sting is that he’s speaking from inside the house: not an outsider mocking belief, but a minister warning that faith becomes brittle when it refuses to look out the window.
"Completely out of touch with reality" lands as a moral and practical indictment. Reality here isn’t just science or modern history; it’s lived experience - the messy evidence of people’s lives refusing to fit a tidy proof-text. Boyd’s subtext is that literalism often functions less as reverence and more as control: a method for shutting down ambiguity, debate, and the discomfort that comes with changing social norms. Literalism reads as certainty, but Boyd implies it’s actually avoidance.
Context matters: Boyd’s career sits in the long 20th-century struggle within American Christianity over modernity, civil rights, sexuality, and the authority of religious institutions. Clergy like Boyd pushed for a faith that could meet the contemporary world without surrendering its spiritual core. The line is crafted to pierce a particular bubble - communities where "the Bible says" ends conversation - by reframing the issue as a failure of contact, not a failure of devotion. The sting is that he’s speaking from inside the house: not an outsider mocking belief, but a minister warning that faith becomes brittle when it refuses to look out the window.
Quote Details
| Topic | Bible |
|---|
More Quotes by Malcolm
Add to List



