"Even a total and universal disarmament does not guarantee the maintenance of peace"
About this Quote
The line lands like a cold glass of water on the dream of a perfectly rational world. Quidde, a German pacifist and Nobel Peace laureate writing in the long shadow of European militarism, isn’t defending arms; he’s puncturing the comforting fantasy that weapons are the only cause of war. His intent is prophylactic: to warn reformers that disarmament, while morally urgent, is not a magic spell that dissolves conflict.
The subtext is almost forensic. Remove guns and you still have the machinery that reaches for them: nationalism that needs enemies, economic rivalry that turns scarcity into ideology, humiliation that demands repayment, leaders who discover that crisis is a shortcut to authority. Quidde is also taking aim at a certain kind of moral accounting, the belief that if you eliminate the tools of violence you eliminate the will to dominate. History, he implies, is more perverse. States can coerce with blockades, coups, propaganda, and policing; “peace” can be maintained as a kind of managed tension, enforced by unequal power and brittle treaties.
The sentence works because of its structure: “Even” concedes the maximalist premise (total, universal disarmament) and then refuses the audience its expected payoff. That rhetorical move turns pacifism from a slogan into a strategy. In Quidde’s era, with empires arming to the teeth and international law still fragile, the warning is both principled and pragmatic: peace is not a one-policy achievement but a political ecosystem. Disarmament is a door; it isn’t the whole house.
The subtext is almost forensic. Remove guns and you still have the machinery that reaches for them: nationalism that needs enemies, economic rivalry that turns scarcity into ideology, humiliation that demands repayment, leaders who discover that crisis is a shortcut to authority. Quidde is also taking aim at a certain kind of moral accounting, the belief that if you eliminate the tools of violence you eliminate the will to dominate. History, he implies, is more perverse. States can coerce with blockades, coups, propaganda, and policing; “peace” can be maintained as a kind of managed tension, enforced by unequal power and brittle treaties.
The sentence works because of its structure: “Even” concedes the maximalist premise (total, universal disarmament) and then refuses the audience its expected payoff. That rhetorical move turns pacifism from a slogan into a strategy. In Quidde’s era, with empires arming to the teeth and international law still fragile, the warning is both principled and pragmatic: peace is not a one-policy achievement but a political ecosystem. Disarmament is a door; it isn’t the whole house.
Quote Details
| Topic | Peace |
|---|
More Quotes by Ludwig
Add to List




