"Every actor has a natural animosity toward every other actor, present or absent, living or dead"
About this Quote
Brooks drops the halo around “the acting community” and replaces it with something sharper: a guild built on scarcity, attention, and the constant audit of who’s getting looked at. The line is funny because it’s so absolutist - “every actor,” “every other actor,” “living or dead” - as if rivalry isn’t a personality flaw but a law of physics. That exaggeration isn’t sloppy; it’s a performer’s instinct for a clean, stage-ready truth.
The intent reads less like petty gossip than a refusal to romanticize the profession. Acting runs on comparison: casting is literally a ranking system disguised as chemistry. Even when you win, you’re winning over someone. Brooks’ “present or absent” nails how competition persists beyond the room: you’re measured against names you’ll never meet, reputations you inherit, legends who still “take” roles by setting the standard. “Living or dead” is the cruelest joke because it admits the industry’s timeline is haunted; an actor is always auditioning against ghosts.
Context matters: Brooks was a silent-film icon who watched the machine move on without sentiment, later becoming a razor-edged writer about fame’s mechanics. Coming from her, the line carries the bite of someone who’s seen how quickly admiration curdles into threat. The subtext is defensive, even tender: if animosity is “natural,” then it’s not moral failure, it’s survival strategy - a way to protect the self when your currency is being chosen.
The intent reads less like petty gossip than a refusal to romanticize the profession. Acting runs on comparison: casting is literally a ranking system disguised as chemistry. Even when you win, you’re winning over someone. Brooks’ “present or absent” nails how competition persists beyond the room: you’re measured against names you’ll never meet, reputations you inherit, legends who still “take” roles by setting the standard. “Living or dead” is the cruelest joke because it admits the industry’s timeline is haunted; an actor is always auditioning against ghosts.
Context matters: Brooks was a silent-film icon who watched the machine move on without sentiment, later becoming a razor-edged writer about fame’s mechanics. Coming from her, the line carries the bite of someone who’s seen how quickly admiration curdles into threat. The subtext is defensive, even tender: if animosity is “natural,” then it’s not moral failure, it’s survival strategy - a way to protect the self when your currency is being chosen.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|
More Quotes by Louise
Add to List
