"Every book is a new journey. I never felt I was an expert on a subject as I embarked on a project"
About this Quote
McCullough is quietly rebuking the fantasy of the all-knowing historian. In an era that rewards authority as performance - the TED-talk certainty, the hot take with a bibliography - he insists on beginnerhood as a professional discipline. The line works because it treats humility not as a personality trait but as method: if you start a book already convinced you understand the subject, you will write propaganda with footnotes.
The subtext is also a defense of narrative history at a time when it can be dismissed as mere storytelling. Calling each book a "new journey" reframes research as lived experience: archives become terrain, contradictions become weather, and the historian becomes a traveler accountable to what he finds, not what he wants to prove. McCullough made his reputation by turning presidents, engineers, and obscure congressional fights into scenes with stakes; that kind of writing depends on curiosity, not mastery. You have to be willing to be surprised, even embarrassed, by the material.
Context matters: McCullough came up in a 20th-century tradition that prized clarity and character over theory, and he spent decades writing for the general public without condescending to it. The modesty here is strategic. It invites readers into the process and reassures them that history is not a sealed verdict delivered from on high, but an act of renewed attention. He’s reminding us that expertise is what you earn after you listen, not what you announce before you begin.
The subtext is also a defense of narrative history at a time when it can be dismissed as mere storytelling. Calling each book a "new journey" reframes research as lived experience: archives become terrain, contradictions become weather, and the historian becomes a traveler accountable to what he finds, not what he wants to prove. McCullough made his reputation by turning presidents, engineers, and obscure congressional fights into scenes with stakes; that kind of writing depends on curiosity, not mastery. You have to be willing to be surprised, even embarrassed, by the material.
Context matters: McCullough came up in a 20th-century tradition that prized clarity and character over theory, and he spent decades writing for the general public without condescending to it. The modesty here is strategic. It invites readers into the process and reassures them that history is not a sealed verdict delivered from on high, but an act of renewed attention. He’s reminding us that expertise is what you earn after you listen, not what you announce before you begin.
Quote Details
| Topic | Book |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by David
Add to List



