"Every good picture leaves the painter eager to start again, unsatisfied, inspired by the rich mine in which he is working, hoping for more energy, more vitality, more time - condemned to painting for life"
About this Quote
The line catches art-making at its most unglamorous truth: a “good picture” doesn’t deliver closure, it delivers appetite. Sloan flips the usual fantasy of completion on its head. Success isn’t a trophy; it’s a trigger. The painter finishes one canvas and immediately feels the next one flickering behind it, because the real subject isn’t the image but the inexhaustible “rich mine” of looking, living, and trying again.
Sloan’s phrasing turns inspiration into something closer to labor and sentence. A mine is valuable, but it’s also dark, repetitive, physically demanding. He’s working-class about genius: the reward for doing it well is more work, and the craving to do it better. “Unsatisfied” isn’t self-pity here; it’s the engine of craft. The dissatisfaction is productive, even necessary, because any finished picture is only a partial capture of vitality - and vitality keeps moving.
The kicker, “condemned to painting for life,” carries a wry, almost stoic bite. Condemned suggests punishment, but Sloan loads it with devotion: the artist as someone who can’t retire from attention. Context matters. Sloan came up through illustration and newspaper work, then became a major figure in the Ashcan School, painting modern urban life with grit and immediacy. In that world, “more time” isn’t a poetic wish; it’s a practical hunger. The city changes, light changes, people change - and the painter, once hooked on that flux, is happily trapped by it.
Sloan’s phrasing turns inspiration into something closer to labor and sentence. A mine is valuable, but it’s also dark, repetitive, physically demanding. He’s working-class about genius: the reward for doing it well is more work, and the craving to do it better. “Unsatisfied” isn’t self-pity here; it’s the engine of craft. The dissatisfaction is productive, even necessary, because any finished picture is only a partial capture of vitality - and vitality keeps moving.
The kicker, “condemned to painting for life,” carries a wry, almost stoic bite. Condemned suggests punishment, but Sloan loads it with devotion: the artist as someone who can’t retire from attention. Context matters. Sloan came up through illustration and newspaper work, then became a major figure in the Ashcan School, painting modern urban life with grit and immediacy. In that world, “more time” isn’t a poetic wish; it’s a practical hunger. The city changes, light changes, people change - and the painter, once hooked on that flux, is happily trapped by it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List
