"Every once in a while, something happens to you that makes you realise that the human race is not quite as bad as it so often seems to be"
About this Quote
The line lands like a quiet corrective to the philosopher's occupational hazard: spending so long diagnosing human error that you start mistaking it for the whole story. Hacking isn't selling optimism. He's admitting how reasonable pessimism can feel in a world that supplies daily evidence for it, then slipping in a counterweight with almost scientific caution: "every once in a while". The phrase functions like a hedge in an academic paper, but emotionally it reads as earned restraint. Goodness, here, isn't constant; it's episodic, sometimes accidental, often noticed only in retrospect.
The subtext is epistemic as much as moral. "Makes you realise" frames decency as a revelation, not a principle. That matters coming from Hacking, whose work obsessed over how categories shape what we can see and say. The quote suggests that cynicism is a kind of default classification system: it organizes experience efficiently, especially in modern life where institutions, headlines, and incentives reward suspicion. Then an encounter (a stranger's patience, a bureaucrat's mercy, a community's competence) breaks the schema. Reality reasserts its messiness.
"Not quite as bad" is doing heavy lifting. It's anti-utopian, anti-sainthood, anti-ted-talk. People remain flawed; the world remains rough; the point is that our usual story about it is overly totalizing. The intent feels less like consolation than calibration: a reminder that the ethical imagination needs evidence too, and that small shocks of kindness can keep our theories from becoming a prison.
The subtext is epistemic as much as moral. "Makes you realise" frames decency as a revelation, not a principle. That matters coming from Hacking, whose work obsessed over how categories shape what we can see and say. The quote suggests that cynicism is a kind of default classification system: it organizes experience efficiently, especially in modern life where institutions, headlines, and incentives reward suspicion. Then an encounter (a stranger's patience, a bureaucrat's mercy, a community's competence) breaks the schema. Reality reasserts its messiness.
"Not quite as bad" is doing heavy lifting. It's anti-utopian, anti-sainthood, anti-ted-talk. People remain flawed; the world remains rough; the point is that our usual story about it is overly totalizing. The intent feels less like consolation than calibration: a reminder that the ethical imagination needs evidence too, and that small shocks of kindness can keep our theories from becoming a prison.
Quote Details
| Topic | Optimism |
|---|
More Quotes by Ian
Add to List








