"Every philosophy is tinged with the coloring of some secret imaginative background, which never emerges explicitly into its train of reasoning"
About this Quote
Philosophy likes to dress in the clean suit of logic, but Whitehead is reminding you to check the lining. Even the most rigorous system, he suggests, is quietly dyed by an authorial inner weather: metaphors, temperaments, unspoken pictures of what the world is like. Coming from a mathematician who helped formalize logic itself, the line lands as a pointed admission rather than a dismissal. He’s not sneering at reason; he’s warning that reason is never the whole story.
The phrasing does a lot of work. “Tinged” is mild, almost polite, but it implies inevitability: you can’t write a philosophy without leaving fingerprints. “Secret imaginative background” reframes imagination as infrastructure, not ornament. And the “never emerges explicitly” clause is the knife twist: the deepest commitments in a system often appear nowhere in the premises, only in what counts as a good explanation, what gets treated as “basic,” what feels elegant or natural. Philosophers argue about conclusions while smuggling in world-pictures.
Context matters. Whitehead wrote in the early 20th century, when logical positivism and the prestige of scientific method were pressuring philosophy to purify itself into verification and syntax. His broader project in process philosophy pushes the opposite: reality as becoming, relation, experience - a cosmic imagination that resists mechanistic snapshots. So the subtext is both methodological and cultural: beware the fantasy that thought can be antiseptic. If you want to critique a philosophy, interrogate its hidden aesthetics - the story it tells itself about what reality should look like when no one is watching.
The phrasing does a lot of work. “Tinged” is mild, almost polite, but it implies inevitability: you can’t write a philosophy without leaving fingerprints. “Secret imaginative background” reframes imagination as infrastructure, not ornament. And the “never emerges explicitly” clause is the knife twist: the deepest commitments in a system often appear nowhere in the premises, only in what counts as a good explanation, what gets treated as “basic,” what feels elegant or natural. Philosophers argue about conclusions while smuggling in world-pictures.
Context matters. Whitehead wrote in the early 20th century, when logical positivism and the prestige of scientific method were pressuring philosophy to purify itself into verification and syntax. His broader project in process philosophy pushes the opposite: reality as becoming, relation, experience - a cosmic imagination that resists mechanistic snapshots. So the subtext is both methodological and cultural: beware the fantasy that thought can be antiseptic. If you want to critique a philosophy, interrogate its hidden aesthetics - the story it tells itself about what reality should look like when no one is watching.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Alfred
Add to List







