"Every piece has its own identity which we develop by the rule 'We know no limits.' We follow the inspiration of the moment and don't worry if what we're playing is alternative, progressive or fusion rock"
About this Quote
Page McConnell is rejecting the museum-label approach to rock: the idea that music needs a genre tag before it can be taken seriously. “Every piece has its own identity” is a quiet rebuke to the marketing logic that flattens songs into categories. He frames composition less as product and more as a living organism, something discovered in real time rather than engineered to fit a scene.
The key move is the rule-as-paradox: “We know no limits.” It’s not an anarchic shrug; it’s a discipline. For jam-oriented musicians, unlimited possibility can turn into indulgence, but McConnell positions boundlessness as a guiding constraint: commit to the moment, keep pushing, don’t self-censor for fear of sounding “too” anything. That’s why the second sentence lands: they “follow the inspiration of the moment” and refuse to “worry” about whether it’s alternative, progressive, or fusion. Those labels are treated as after-the-fact paperwork, not creative inputs.
Context matters here. McConnell’s world (Phish and the broader jam circuit) has long lived in the shadow of rock’s status hierarchies: critics who valorize tight songcraft and sneer at improvisation, audiences who want both freedom and coherence. The subtext is a defense strategy and a manifesto: if you’re constantly being told your music is unfocused or “not real” whatever, you stop auditioning for acceptance. You make the piece the only authority, and you let the taxonomy catch up later - or not at all.
The key move is the rule-as-paradox: “We know no limits.” It’s not an anarchic shrug; it’s a discipline. For jam-oriented musicians, unlimited possibility can turn into indulgence, but McConnell positions boundlessness as a guiding constraint: commit to the moment, keep pushing, don’t self-censor for fear of sounding “too” anything. That’s why the second sentence lands: they “follow the inspiration of the moment” and refuse to “worry” about whether it’s alternative, progressive, or fusion. Those labels are treated as after-the-fact paperwork, not creative inputs.
Context matters here. McConnell’s world (Phish and the broader jam circuit) has long lived in the shadow of rock’s status hierarchies: critics who valorize tight songcraft and sneer at improvisation, audiences who want both freedom and coherence. The subtext is a defense strategy and a manifesto: if you’re constantly being told your music is unfocused or “not real” whatever, you stop auditioning for acceptance. You make the piece the only authority, and you let the taxonomy catch up later - or not at all.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Page
Add to List
