Skip to main content

Science & Tech Quote by Miguel de Icaza

"Every piece of software written today is likely going to infringe on someone else's patent"

About this Quote

A chill runs through de Icaza's line because it treats patent infringement not as a rare moral lapse, but as an ambient condition of modern coding. The phrasing "every piece" is deliberately maximalist: he's not warning about a few bad actors or sloppy teams, he's indicting the system itself. And "likely" does a lot of work, telegraphing that this isn't conspiracy thinking; it's the probabilistic reality of building anything in a world where ideas have been diced into legal property.

The specific intent is pragmatic, almost managerial: if infringement is the default risk, then patents become less a shield for inventors than a cudgel for incumbents, trolls, and anyone with a litigation budget. His subtext is that software's combinatorial nature makes patent boundaries absurdly porous. Real programs are mosaics: protocols, algorithms, UI conventions, tiny optimizations. When those building blocks are patented at scale, "innovation" becomes a minefield navigated by lawyers rather than engineers.

Context matters: de Icaza is a prominent open-source figure, and open source is uniquely vulnerable to patent aggression because it distributes code widely and invites reuse. The quote doubles as a defense of openness and a critique of policy that treats software like a discrete, patentable machine part. It works rhetorically because it's both a threat assessment and a cultural diagnosis: we've built a knowledge economy where creating is easy, but permission is expensive, and the legal uncertainty is the point.
More Quotes by Miguel Add to List
Miguel de Icaza on Software Patent Risk
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

Mexico Flag

Miguel de Icaza (born November 23, 1972) is a Scientist from Mexico.

23 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

Marc Andreessen, Businessman