"Every reform, however necessary, will by weak minds be carried to an excess, that itself will need reforming"
About this Quote
Reform, Coleridge suggests, is never the end of the story; it is the beginning of a new kind of mess. The line is built like a trap for idealists: it grants that reform can be "necessary" while warning that necessity doesn’t protect it from being distorted by human limitations. The barb is in "weak minds" - not simple stupidity, but the kind of mental laziness that confuses moral certainty with totalizing solutions. Coleridge is diagnosing a political habit: once a cause acquires momentum, it attracts people who want the clarity of a slogan more than the complexity of a system.
The sentence works because it’s cyclical. Reform begets excess; excess begets reform. That rhythm smuggles in a bleak view of progress as self-correcting only through repeated overcorrection. It also lets Coleridge sound like a moderate without having to defend any particular status quo. He isn't arguing against change; he's arguing against the intoxicating idea that change can be pure.
Context matters: Coleridge lived through the aftershocks of the French Revolution, a moment when emancipatory rhetoric turned, in practice, into terror and reaction. British debates over rights, representation, and authority weren’t abstract - they were haunted by the spectacle of reforms escalating into ideological purges. The subtext is caution aimed less at tyrants than at reformers themselves: if you can't tolerate limits, you'll end up rebuilding the very machinery you set out to dismantle, only with a new paint job and fresh victims.
The sentence works because it’s cyclical. Reform begets excess; excess begets reform. That rhythm smuggles in a bleak view of progress as self-correcting only through repeated overcorrection. It also lets Coleridge sound like a moderate without having to defend any particular status quo. He isn't arguing against change; he's arguing against the intoxicating idea that change can be pure.
Context matters: Coleridge lived through the aftershocks of the French Revolution, a moment when emancipatory rhetoric turned, in practice, into terror and reaction. British debates over rights, representation, and authority weren’t abstract - they were haunted by the spectacle of reforms escalating into ideological purges. The subtext is caution aimed less at tyrants than at reformers themselves: if you can't tolerate limits, you'll end up rebuilding the very machinery you set out to dismantle, only with a new paint job and fresh victims.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Samuel
Add to List









