"Every step in the progress of this study has tended to obliterate the technical barriers by which logicians have sought to separate the inquiries relating to the several parts of man's nature"
About this Quote
Owen is quietly picking a fight with the gatekeepers of Victorian knowledge. The sentence looks like patient, incremental science talk, but the intent is expansive: each new “step” in his research doesn’t just add facts; it dissolves the neat professional borders that “logicians” use to police what counts as a legitimate question about humans. The verb choice matters. “Obliterate” isn’t a gentle merging of disciplines; it’s demolition. Owen frames the old partitions as “technical barriers” - not moral truths or natural divisions, but man-made scaffolding that can be kicked away by evidence.
The subtext is a bid for jurisdiction. As a leading anatomist and paleontologist in a century obsessed with classification, Owen is arguing that you can’t carve “man’s nature” into tidy compartments - reason over here, body over there, instincts somewhere else - and expect reality to cooperate. He’s also implying that the people insisting on separation are doing it to protect a method, a status, maybe even a worldview. “Logicians” stands in for philosophers and system-builders who preferred clean categories to messy continuity.
Context sharpens the edge. Owen worked in the era when comparative anatomy, embryology, and geology were beginning to reframe humanity as part of a biological continuum, a pressure that would soon explode in Darwin’s wake. This line anticipates that cultural tremor: once the walls between mind, body, and behavior start to crumble, the study of humans stops being a philosophical parlor game and becomes a scientific problem with consequences.
The subtext is a bid for jurisdiction. As a leading anatomist and paleontologist in a century obsessed with classification, Owen is arguing that you can’t carve “man’s nature” into tidy compartments - reason over here, body over there, instincts somewhere else - and expect reality to cooperate. He’s also implying that the people insisting on separation are doing it to protect a method, a status, maybe even a worldview. “Logicians” stands in for philosophers and system-builders who preferred clean categories to messy continuity.
Context sharpens the edge. Owen worked in the era when comparative anatomy, embryology, and geology were beginning to reframe humanity as part of a biological continuum, a pressure that would soon explode in Darwin’s wake. This line anticipates that cultural tremor: once the walls between mind, body, and behavior start to crumble, the study of humans stops being a philosophical parlor game and becomes a scientific problem with consequences.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Richard
Add to List




