"Everything great in the world comes from neurotics. They alone have founded our religions and composed our masterpieces"
About this Quote
Proust lobs this provocation like a salon grenade: greatness, he implies, is less a gift than a symptom. In calling the makers of religions and masterpieces “neurotics,” he’s not diagnosing them in a clinical sense so much as naming a temperament - the mind that can’t comfortably fit inside ordinary life, that keeps worrying an experience until it yields meaning. The line flatters art while quietly insulting comfort: the well-adjusted person may be pleasant company, but they don’t rewrite the human script.
The intent is partly self-justification. Proust, famously sickly, socially hyper-attuned, and obsessively introspective, built an entire cathedral of prose out of sensitivity and fixation. “Neurosis” becomes a kind of engine: anxiety as attention, compulsion as craft, discomfort as the pressure that forces form. He’s also poking at bourgeois common sense - the idea that health, balance, and productivity are the proper goals. For Proust, balance is often just amnesia with good manners.
The subtext has a darker edge: if the best things come from the neurotic, then greatness carries a cost, and society’s masterpieces are, in a way, receipts for private suffering. Pairing religions with art sharpens the claim. Both are systems for converting inner turmoil into shared structure - narratives, rituals, symphonies, novels - that make other people’s lives feel less contingent. Proust isn’t romanticizing misery; he’s arguing that obsession, not serenity, is what leaves a mark.
The intent is partly self-justification. Proust, famously sickly, socially hyper-attuned, and obsessively introspective, built an entire cathedral of prose out of sensitivity and fixation. “Neurosis” becomes a kind of engine: anxiety as attention, compulsion as craft, discomfort as the pressure that forces form. He’s also poking at bourgeois common sense - the idea that health, balance, and productivity are the proper goals. For Proust, balance is often just amnesia with good manners.
The subtext has a darker edge: if the best things come from the neurotic, then greatness carries a cost, and society’s masterpieces are, in a way, receipts for private suffering. Pairing religions with art sharpens the claim. Both are systems for converting inner turmoil into shared structure - narratives, rituals, symphonies, novels - that make other people’s lives feel less contingent. Proust isn’t romanticizing misery; he’s arguing that obsession, not serenity, is what leaves a mark.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|
More Quotes by Marcel
Add to List
