"Everything that happens once can never happen again. But everything that happens twice will surely happen a third time"
About this Quote
Coelho’s line flatters the reader’s hunger for pattern while warning how quickly pattern hardens into fate. The first sentence gestures toward the romance of uniqueness: the once-in-a-lifetime kiss, the singular catastrophe, the unrepeatable turning point. It’s a little metaphysical, a little consoling. Then the pivot lands like a streetwise proverb. If it happens twice, don’t call it coincidence; call it a trajectory. The quote works because it smuggles determinism into a self-help-shaped wrapper.
The subtext is about habit and denial. “Once” preserves our innocence: we can still believe in bad luck, in exceptions, in the story where we learn and move on. “Twice” is the moment the story changes genres. Now it’s about systems: the choices you keep making, the kind of partners you keep choosing, the compromises you keep normalizing, the political cycles you keep shrugging at. Coelho isn’t predicting the future so much as diagnosing how humans outsource responsibility to hope until repetition makes the bill undeniable.
Context matters: Coelho’s novels trade in parable logic, where life’s chaos can be read as a legible moral plot if you pay attention. That’s why the quote feels both mystical and practical. It offers a narrative shortcut: treat recurrence as instruction. The danger is its seductive certainty; not everything that happens twice “surely” happens a third time. But the pressure of that word is the point. It dares you to intervene before the pattern becomes your personality.
The subtext is about habit and denial. “Once” preserves our innocence: we can still believe in bad luck, in exceptions, in the story where we learn and move on. “Twice” is the moment the story changes genres. Now it’s about systems: the choices you keep making, the kind of partners you keep choosing, the compromises you keep normalizing, the political cycles you keep shrugging at. Coelho isn’t predicting the future so much as diagnosing how humans outsource responsibility to hope until repetition makes the bill undeniable.
Context matters: Coelho’s novels trade in parable logic, where life’s chaos can be read as a legible moral plot if you pay attention. That’s why the quote feels both mystical and practical. It offers a narrative shortcut: treat recurrence as instruction. The danger is its seductive certainty; not everything that happens twice “surely” happens a third time. But the pressure of that word is the point. It dares you to intervene before the pattern becomes your personality.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|---|
| Source | Unverified source: O Alquimista (The Alchemist) (Paulo Coelho, 1988)
Evidence: Part II (exact page varies by edition; commonly cited as p. 184 in some English editions). Primary-source attribution is to Coelho’s novel O Alquimista (first published 1988 in Portuguese). The English wording appears in the 1993 English translation (Alan R. Clarke). The quote is spoken in-contex... Other candidates (2) Paulo Coelho (Paulo Coelho) compilation98.2% rsons life p 167 everything that happens once can never happen again but everything that happens twice will surely ha... Alchemical Quotes of Paulo Coelho (Sreechinth C) compilation95.3% ... Everything that happens once can never happen again . But everything that happens twice will surely happen a thir... |
More Quotes by Paulo
Add to List







